“How many baby mamas?”: Fans lose it after Stefon Diggs is seen with another baby mama right after reuniting with Cardi B

Stefon Diggs did the dad thing this week, and social media, predictably, couldn't let it slide. The New England Patriots wide receiver popped out on May 15 to celebrate his daughter Peyton's first birthday with baby mama Cayy Benji. Carnival theme, balloons, the whole nine. Sweet moment. Chaotic context and fans had a few thoughts.Because, well, you know the backstory by now.The loudest reaction online was pure disbelief at Diggs' baby count. People were genuinely losing it, the general mood was that a new Diggs-baby-mama video drops every single day, and nobody can keep track anymore. The sheer number of women and children involved had fans treating the whole situation like a running joke. Then there was obviously the Cardi B angle. Cardi has been vocal about her frustrations before, and fans weren't shy about pointing out that seeing Diggs at a birthday party with another baby mama probably isn't sitting easy. The general sentiment, it's giving messy, and she signed up for it.But not everyone was in clown mode. A quieter faction online actually defended him, the argument being that people drag absent fathers constantly, so when a man actually shows up for his kid, the pile-on feels unfair. A few people pointed out that Diggs looked stiff and kept his distance from Cayy Benji, which they read as him being respectful of boundaries rather than rekindling anything. It's a thin line, but some fans gave him credit for walking it.Oh, and somehow, in the middle of all this, people found time to comment on his outfit. Apparently, the crop top/jacket combo is a permanent fixture at this point. Man has a uniform.Peyton is Diggs' daughter with Instagram model Cayy Benji, born in April 2025, making her one of three kids Diggs welcomed in the same calendar year. Yes, three. He also has a son with Cardi B, born in November 2025, and a daughter, Charliee, with Aileen Lopera. That's on top of daughters Nova and Shiloh from earlier relationships. Six kids. Six women. The math is doing something.So when Diggs rolled up to a carnival-themed first birthday party looking all co-parenting goals, the timeline went off.That's the question, isn't it? Cardi welcomed her son with Diggs in November 2025 and has been navigating a very public, very complicated family situation ever since. Peyton's birthday party is just the latest reminder that Diggs' world is crowded, and Cardi is one of many women in it. Fans are watching closely to see how long she stays unbothered.At the end of the day, Peyton turned one. Dad showed up. The internet showed up. Business as usual in Stefon Diggs' world.