The New England Patriots are celebrating another playoff breakthrough, but inside the organization, concern has quietly replaced confidence. It was all focus on Drake Maye in the AFC Championship when all focus was not on the scoreboard, but the rookie quarter back Drake Maye had his throwing shoulder after being hit. The time was short, but its effect has been long since the last whistle.
With the
Super Bowl approaching, the Patriots are walking a fine line between optimism and uncertainty. Maye finished the game without leaving the field, yet his body language told a different story. Coaches have remained cautious, and medical silence from the team has only fueled speculation. Now, outside experts are stepping in to fill the information gap.
Medical experts weigh in as concern grows around Drake Maye
The timing could not be more delicate. Maye enters the biggest game of his young career with questions surrounding his health, his protection, and whether his shoulder can handle another four quarters under pressure.
One of the first detailed evaluations came from Dr. Jesse Morse, who reviewed the play and offered cautious reassurance while outlining real risks.
“Most likely possibilities: posterior capsular sprain or superior/posterior labral tear (10-11 o’clock) I think he got lucky, and it’s likely a sprain especially since he threw a dime 2 plays later to Mack Hollins,” Dr.
Jesse Morse wrote on X. “Is he sore? Yes Did he significantly dislocate his shoulder? No, unlikely This isn’t the mechanism for an AC sprain.”
While that assessment suggests Maye avoided serious structural damage, his performance afterward raised fresh concerns. He completed just 10 passes for 86 yards, his lowest output of the season. The Patriots still advanced, but the drop in efficiency was impossible to ignore.
Former NFL team physician Dr. David Chao offered a more cautious perspective, comparing Maye’s situation to the opposing quarterback’s health.
“I am far more concerned about Drake May’s right shoulder than Sam Darnold’s oblique heading into the Super Bowl. I’m not saying Drake May won’t play, and I’m not saying this is a season-ending issue,” Dr. Davis Chao said. “I’m saying that, as of Monday — nearly two weeks before the Super Bowl — the concern level is much higher for Drake May’s throwing shoulder than it is for Sam Darnold’s oblique.”
For now, the Patriots are buying time with rest and limited disclosure. Whether that shoulder responds remains the defining question heading into football’s biggest stage.