The Carolina Panthers may have finally found their future with Bryce Young. But the Pittsburgh Steelers are still stuck in a cycle of short-term fixes, according to former NFL MVP Cam Newton, and the latest one, he thinks, wears No. 8. The Steelers signed veteran quarterback
Aaron Rodgers this offseason in hopes of stabilizing a position that’s been unsettled since Ben Roethlisberger retired in 2021. But Newton isn’t convinced the move will solve anything long-term. On his 4th & 1 podcast, the former Panthers star gave a blunt take, calling Rodgers nothing more than a temporary solution. The team’s latest quarterback decision, he thinks, might buy them another season or two, but it does little to build a sustainable future at the position.
Cam Newton questions whether Aaron Rodgers can really be the answer in Pittsburgh Steelers
During his 4th & 1 podcast, Panthers legend Cam Newton offered his candid assessment of the Steelers’ quarterback strategy. He said, “I don’t think Aaron Rodgers has anything else to prove,” adding, “I don’t think he’s saying, ‘I have to win a Super Bowl.’ If he wins a Super Bowl, he’s retired. This very well may be Aaron Rodgers’ last hurrah. It would have been his last hurrah last year if it wasn’t so meh. If they would have went to the playoffs, if they would have went to the AFC Championship, the Super Bowl, he would have been able to say, ‘I’ve seen the mountaintop.
I ain’t got it in me.’ Now, you get to a situation where it’s like, does he really have to perform? Because he’s a Band-Aid at this particular point. A quality Band-Aid.”
Pittsburgh Steelers trapped in NFL no man’s land with limited playoff chances and low draft position
Newton’s analysis hits a nerve in Pittsburgh. The team has lacked the breakthrough needed to make deep playoff runs while also never reaching the bottom of the standings where they could draft a high-end quarterback prospect. That middle-of-the-pack status means the Steelers are neither contending nor able to draft the kind of rookie passer who could change their fortunes. Rodgers’ Achilles injury in 2023 made people even more worried about whether he can stay healthy and play well at this point in his career. Newton’s comment echoes what many are thinking – the Steelers need to stop relying on older quarterbacks and find a long-term answer.
Bringing in Aaron Rodgers might not be enough to fix Steelers’ quarterback cycle
In a league where quarterback continuity is vital, Pittsburgh may continue to search longer than they planned. With the NFC’s rebuilding Panthers potentially ready to capitalize on quarterback stability with Bryce Young, the contrast between the two franchises becomes even more striking. The Steelers can hope Rodgers buys them time – but if history is any indication, time alone may not solve their long-term quarterback needs.
Also read:
"Nothing is working": Matthew Stafford’s wife Kelly Stafford exhausted over parenting challenges as Los Angeles Rams QB readies for 2025 NFL seasonUnless Pittsburgh commits to a long-term vision at the most important position in football, they risk repeating this same offseason carousel again in 2026.