“It’s been a struggle”: Auston Matthews ripped for shrinking under pressure in Toronto’s worst stretch

The frustration in Toronto this season isn’t just coming from fans. The Maple Leafs entered the year with expectations of finally shaping into a true Stanley Cup contender, yet the first two months have delivered more inconsistency than confidence. Sitting near the bottom of the Eastern Conference standings, the team has struggled to find its rhythm, and a surprising amount of blame has shifted toward the player who should be leading the way, captain Auston Matthews.

Known for elite scoring and big-moment production, the Arizona native has looked noticeably out of sync, leaving questions about whether his slow start is just a slump or a sign of something deeper. Now, a former Leaf is sounding the alarm, warning that patience shouldn’t overshadow accountability.

Why Auston Matthews’ quiet start is sparking concern across Leafs Nation

Through 20 games, Matthews has 17 points, well below the lofty standard he’s expected to meet as one of the NHL’s premier forwards. Injuries have played a small factor, but former defenseman Carlo Colaiacovo suggested that the issue goes beyond missed games.


Speaking on Daily Faceoff LIVE, he didn’t mince words: “My concern about him is not being the player that everybody expects him to be.” He emphasized that the move to give Matthews the captaincy wasn’t symbolic; it came with responsibility. “Production-wise, it’s been a struggle for him to do that,” Colaiacovo added.

His critique isn’t just about numbers. Leadership in the NHL is measured through moments, especially when the team is struggling. Colaiacovo went further, saying Matthews must show the kind of initiative expected from a top-tier star. “If Auston Matthews is supposed to be the captain of this team and one of the top five to ten players in this league, he’s got to find it within himself to lead on his own.”

What’s striking is that while the Leafs are sputtering, teammates like William Nylander continue to produce. That contrast fuels Colaiacovo’s bottom line: “Auston Matthews needs to find a way…good back or not, he has to put the team on his back and lead them.”

For Toronto, the path forward hinges on its captain rediscovering his dominance. If Matthews snaps out of this early funk, the Leafs still have time to turn their season around. If not, the questions won’t stop, they’ll get louder.

Also Read: NHL update: Carter Hart sends strong message as he returns to NHL ice after Hockey Canada acquittal


Get an chance to win ₹5000 Amazon Voucher by taking part in India's Biggest Habit Index! Take the survey here