Gurgaon’s problem is it’s remote-controlled from Chandigarh, Rao Inderjit Singh says at TOI Townhall
When Rao Inderjit Singh said "we don't have the autonomy we need", the audience nodded in appreciation and agreement. It was a nod both to the minister's candour as well as his ability to get to the nucleus of the problem that affects a Gurgaon resident all year – the city's acute infrastructure and governance problem.
There are few who know and can read the city as well as Singh, who is currently serving his sixth term as MP from Gurgaon and his third stint as a minister in the central govt led by Narendra Modi. So, when a question came on the city's governance, Singh's diagnosis was quick and precise. Despite the presence of senior state govt functionaries in the city and frequent visits by both the current and former CMs, key decisions regarding Gurgaon's future, he observed, continue to be made in Chandigarh. "Gurgaon is remote-controlled from Chandigarh," he said, speaking at the second edition of TOI's #WeMakeGurgaon Townhall, held on Saturday at Indiabulls Centrum Park in Sector 103.
In a conversation that covered a spectrum of subjects, from the city's rain miseries to his own political career, the Union minister offered a forthright and wide-ranging address, candidly acknowledging deficiencies and also laying out his vision for what is to come in the months and years ahead.
Speaking about the "Chandigarh-centric approach" that slows down decision-making in a city that helps generate the bulk of the state's revenues, Singh said, "Even when the CM is in Gurgaon, the files still have to go to Chandigarh."
He acknowledged that Gurgaon contributes 60-65% of the state's total revenue but struggles to receive proportional attention in terms of development funds and infrastructure support. "When we contribute this much, we are right to expect a fair share in return," he said.
Recalling the tenure of former CM Manohar Lal Khattar, Singh mentioned the move to set up a grievance redress committee as a positive step, which remains active and its results visible. "But administrative limitations persist," he said. "Even Nayab Singh Saini, who now leads the grievance committee, shows interest in Gurgaon. But the problem is not intent — it is structure. We still lack the leeway to take decisions on the ground," Singh said.
The minister went on to underline Gurgaon and south Haryana's deep-rooted political loyalty to BJP, seen in the consistent support for the party in both state and national elections. "These constituencies have made it possible for BJP to form the govt. Our voters here deserve more focus, more attention, and more support. And not just because they vote for us but because their needs are real, urgent and growing."
To a question on whether Haryana should consider making Gurgaon its capital, Singh responded by saying it was an impractical idea. "Not a chance," he said. "Gurgaon is already bursting at the seams. We don't have enough water, infrastructure or public services to absorb that level of institutional expansion. Before we talk about a capital, we need to upgrade our current systems."
However, he added, "Given our legal infrastructure and population of professionals, I believe Gurgaon should house a high court".
Singh mentioned progress on highways, arterial roads and flyovers, all designed to ease the city's notorious traffic problems and improve inter-sector mobility. But there are major gaps still, he admitted. Waterlogging and inadequate sewerage systems continue to plague many areas, especially during monsoon. "Basic issues still remain. But we're actively working on them. These are not being ignored," he assured.
Asked if Gurugram Metropolitan Development Authority (GMDA), created with the vision of enabling unified urban planning for a city with too many agencies and little coordination, had, in his opinion, fulfilled its purpose, Singh said it continues to evolve and holds significant promise. "The intention behind GMDA was to bring Gurgaon under a single development umbrella. It's a work in progress, but we've taken the first steps towards autonomy."
For representatives of RWAs in new sectors around Dwarka Expressway who were among those in the audience, this was an opportunity to voice their grievances before their MP. Lack of public transport, erratic sanitation services, frequent water shortages, and poor road maintenance were the four main problems they brought up. Singh listened, took notes, and assured them he would take these up with the appropriate departments. "I will personally follow up," he said. "Your voices matter."
Many in the audience said this was the first time they had been able to speak directly to their elected representative in such an open and public forum. "I'm here to listen and I will act. I may not be able to solve everything immediately, but I promise you will be heard," was Singh's message to them.
As the conversation moved to his long political career, and whether he might hang up his boots as he has hinted before, Singh dismissed a question on whether he would turn his attention to state politics with a shake of the head. Does he see himself as a future CM contender? "The chief minister's chair is a bed of thorns," he said with a smile. "I'm 75 years old. I have no ambition to pursue that path." His political journey, he said, would continue in whichever direction the party deemed fit. But he made it clear he had no plans to contest another Lok Sabha election. "I think it's time for someone else. If the party insists, I will follow its directive, but my own preference is to step aside from electoral politics."
He made it clear that stepping away from Parliament would not mean stepping away from public service. "Being an MP ties me to Delhi and central responsibilities. Many of the issues Gurgaon faces are local and require state-level coordination. It's frustrating not to be able to give them the attention they deserve. I'm not going anywhere. I'll continue to serve, just perhaps in a different capacity." For residents who packed the venue to listen to him, Singh had a message: "The Gurgaon of tomorrow will only thrive through cooperation, transparency and sustained civic involvement."
Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays, public holidays, and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
In a conversation that covered a spectrum of subjects, from the city's rain miseries to his own political career, the Union minister offered a forthright and wide-ranging address, candidly acknowledging deficiencies and also laying out his vision for what is to come in the months and years ahead.
Speaking about the "Chandigarh-centric approach" that slows down decision-making in a city that helps generate the bulk of the state's revenues, Singh said, "Even when the CM is in Gurgaon, the files still have to go to Chandigarh."
He acknowledged that Gurgaon contributes 60-65% of the state's total revenue but struggles to receive proportional attention in terms of development funds and infrastructure support. "When we contribute this much, we are right to expect a fair share in return," he said.
Recalling the tenure of former CM Manohar Lal Khattar, Singh mentioned the move to set up a grievance redress committee as a positive step, which remains active and its results visible. "But administrative limitations persist," he said. "Even Nayab Singh Saini, who now leads the grievance committee, shows interest in Gurgaon. But the problem is not intent — it is structure. We still lack the leeway to take decisions on the ground," Singh said.
The minister went on to underline Gurgaon and south Haryana's deep-rooted political loyalty to BJP, seen in the consistent support for the party in both state and national elections. "These constituencies have made it possible for BJP to form the govt. Our voters here deserve more focus, more attention, and more support. And not just because they vote for us but because their needs are real, urgent and growing."
However, he added, "Given our legal infrastructure and population of professionals, I believe Gurgaon should house a high court".
Singh mentioned progress on highways, arterial roads and flyovers, all designed to ease the city's notorious traffic problems and improve inter-sector mobility. But there are major gaps still, he admitted. Waterlogging and inadequate sewerage systems continue to plague many areas, especially during monsoon. "Basic issues still remain. But we're actively working on them. These are not being ignored," he assured.
Asked if Gurugram Metropolitan Development Authority (GMDA), created with the vision of enabling unified urban planning for a city with too many agencies and little coordination, had, in his opinion, fulfilled its purpose, Singh said it continues to evolve and holds significant promise. "The intention behind GMDA was to bring Gurgaon under a single development umbrella. It's a work in progress, but we've taken the first steps towards autonomy."
For representatives of RWAs in new sectors around Dwarka Expressway who were among those in the audience, this was an opportunity to voice their grievances before their MP. Lack of public transport, erratic sanitation services, frequent water shortages, and poor road maintenance were the four main problems they brought up. Singh listened, took notes, and assured them he would take these up with the appropriate departments. "I will personally follow up," he said. "Your voices matter."
Many in the audience said this was the first time they had been able to speak directly to their elected representative in such an open and public forum. "I'm here to listen and I will act. I may not be able to solve everything immediately, but I promise you will be heard," was Singh's message to them.
As the conversation moved to his long political career, and whether he might hang up his boots as he has hinted before, Singh dismissed a question on whether he would turn his attention to state politics with a shake of the head. Does he see himself as a future CM contender? "The chief minister's chair is a bed of thorns," he said with a smile. "I'm 75 years old. I have no ambition to pursue that path." His political journey, he said, would continue in whichever direction the party deemed fit. But he made it clear he had no plans to contest another Lok Sabha election. "I think it's time for someone else. If the party insists, I will follow its directive, but my own preference is to step aside from electoral politics."
He made it clear that stepping away from Parliament would not mean stepping away from public service. "Being an MP ties me to Delhi and central responsibilities. Many of the issues Gurgaon faces are local and require state-level coordination. It's frustrating not to be able to give them the attention they deserve. I'm not going anywhere. I'll continue to serve, just perhaps in a different capacity." For residents who packed the venue to listen to him, Singh had a message: "The Gurgaon of tomorrow will only thrive through cooperation, transparency and sustained civic involvement."
Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays, public holidays, and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.
Top Comment
A
Abhishek
32 days ago
It's high time that Government should start focusing upon other parts of Haryana also. Why Gurgaon is only being focused upon?Development should take place everywhere.Read allPost comment
Popular from City
- ‘Gave them Scorpio, they still wanted Rs 36 lakh’: Woman tortured, set ablaze by in-laws in Greater Noida; husband held, others on run
- Hours after Supreme Court order, man slaps woman 9 times for feeding stray dogs in Ghaziabad; arrested
- Kolkata shocker: Customs dog mauls 4-year-old at airport; handler absconds as family cries for help, FIR filed
- Operation Sindoor fallout: Masood Azhar's Jaish-e-Mohammad plots comeback with 313 mosques doubling as terror hubs; plans Rs 3.91 billion fundraising drive
- Karnataka’s transport minister orders aggregators to stop bike-taxi services in Bengaluru; but captains and riders happily vroom away
end of article
Trending Stories
- Cheteshwar Pujara announces retirement from all forms of Indian cricket
09:22 Evening news wrap: India temporarily suspends most postal services to US; Jaishankar's firm stance amid trade tensions with US & more- Gisele Bündchen accused of erasing Tom Brady’s son Jack from her life and focusing on her new family
03:40 Florida crash: Punjabi truck driver Harjinder Singh flight risk, not eligible for bond, rules court- Mark Zuckerberg's Meta freezes AI hiring and 'bans' employees from…
- Meghan Markle furious over Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce as her Netflix launch gets sabotaged by New Heights podcast
- Vanessa Bryant finally breaks silence on wild pregnancy rumors with a wild response featuring a Rihanna meme
Featured in city
10:36 Hours after Supreme Court order, man slaps woman 9 times for feeding stray dogs in Ghaziabad; arrested- 3-year-old 'kidnapped' Surat boy found murdered in dustbin of train washroom at Mumbai’s LTT; cousin prime suspect
03:39 Ahmedabad school murder: ‘My son’s killer deserves nothing less than hanging,’ says Nayan’s father; slams school’s role- ‘Gave them Scorpio, they still wanted Rs 36 lakh’: Woman tortured, set ablaze by in-laws in Greater Noida; husband held, others on run
- Teacher mixes pesticide in drinking water: 11 students fall ill in Telangana; accused did it to frame colleagues
- Thane: 25-year-old held for murdering 75-year-old woman; attacked her 97-year-old mother during robbery
Visual Stories
- How to grow strawberries in balcony pots
- 10 animals known for kind nature
- 8 vitamin deficiencies that are linked to hair loss
- Gaurav Khanna’s top 10 stylish looks
- Khaled Hosseini's The Kite Runner: 5 heart touching quotes from the book
- Mahima Nambiar: A symphony of grace, charm, and radiant smiles
- Rashmika Mandanna to Tamannaah Bhatia: South divas' best pictures of the week
- Super Dancer Chapter 5 judge Shilpa Shetty is the ultimate style Queen
- In Pic: Radiant Pictures of Siddhi Idnani
- Ganesh Chaturthi 2025: Bollywood songs to get you into the spirit of Bappa’s celebrations
Videos
03:18 Lavrov Declares Putin Won’t Meet Zelensky, Shocks Trump | ‘How Can We Meet Leader Pretending To Be…’03:39 Trump 'DECLARES WAR', Slaps 25% More Tariffs As India Refuses To Snub Putin, Reject Russian Oil03:07 India’s Russian Oil Defiance ANGERS Trump; Delhi Gets 24-hour Ultimatum | ‘Stop Buying Now, Or…’04:37 PM Modi's Big Declaration In 1st Visit To J&K After Pahalgam Attack | 'Pak Attacked Kashmiriyat'04:08 Sikkim: Landslide Hits Indian Army Camp After River Teesta Swells; 3 Personnel Killed, 6 Missing09:15 FULL SPEECH: Tharoor Mocks Pak's Kashmir 'Dream' In Guyana | 'They Want Something They Don't Have'06:36 PM Modi's Shocking New Op Sindoor Reveal | '9 Terror Hideouts In Pak Destroyed In Just 22 Mins'04:26 Indian Army Shares 1st Video Of Missiles, Russian S-400 In Action During Op Sindoor Against Pak04:04 India's Ballistic Missiles Spook Munir; Pak Army HQ To Be Moved After Nur Khan Base Attack | Report
Photostories
- 5 underrated movies of Saif Ali Khan that deserve a rewatch
- Neurologist reveals 5 signs that someone might be at risk of dementia
- 'Param Sundari' Janhvi Kapoor's latest ethnic outings!
- 5 delicious low-calorie desserts made with high-protein paneer
- Paris, New York, Tokyo and more; World’s most walkable cities for travellers who love exploring on foot
- Top 5 Korean romance dramas on OTT that will make you fall in love again
- Experts reveal: These 7 high-fibre foods could help protect against cancer
- 4 foods to combine with walnuts to boost omega-3 fatty acid content
- 'Vote Chor Gaddi Chhodd': Rahul Gandhi’s Bihar yatra picks steam as he campaigns on bike with Tejashwi - In pics
- Weekly Horoscope: August 25 to 31, 2025
Top Trends
Up Next