This story is from February 14, 2020
UK parents lose court appeal to keep baby on life support
LONDON: The parents of a baby declared brain dead by doctors have lost the latest round of a legal battle in
Britain's Court of Appeal on Friday rejected an attempt by
The baby was starved of oxygen due to complications at birth, and was born not breathing and without a heartbeat. He has been on a ventilator ever since.
Judges at both courts agreed with doctors that Midrar Ali had experienced "irreversible brain stem death" by Oct 1, when he was 14 days old. Three appeals judges ruled Friday that doctors could lawfully "cease to mechanically ventilate" the baby.
One of the judges,
"There is no basis for contemplating that any further tests would result in a different outcome," he said.
The baby's parents, who live in Manchester in northwest England, do not accept that his condition is irreversible and want the courts to consider opinions from foreign experts.
Their lawyer, David Foster, said the couple was considering an appeal to the Supreme Court.
The case is a latest in a series of legal challenges by parents to doctors in Britain's state-funded National
The cases often become flashpoints for debates on the rights of children and parents, the responsibilities of hospitals and the role of the state.
Under British law, it is common for courts to intervene when parents and doctors disagree on the treatment of a child. In such cases, the rights of the child take primacy over the parents' right to decide what's best for their offspring.
Britain
's courts to keep him on life support.Britain's Court of Appeal on Friday rejected an attempt by
Karwan Ali
andShokhan Namiq
to overturn a High Court order that doctors could stop treating their infant son,Midrar Ali
.Judges at both courts agreed with doctors that Midrar Ali had experienced "irreversible brain stem death" by Oct 1, when he was 14 days old. Three appeals judges ruled Friday that doctors could lawfully "cease to mechanically ventilate" the baby.
One of the judges,
Andrew McFarlane
, said Midrar Ali no longer had a "brain that is recognizable as such."The baby's parents, who live in Manchester in northwest England, do not accept that his condition is irreversible and want the courts to consider opinions from foreign experts.
Their lawyer, David Foster, said the couple was considering an appeal to the Supreme Court.
The case is a latest in a series of legal challenges by parents to doctors in Britain's state-funded National
Health Service
.The cases often become flashpoints for debates on the rights of children and parents, the responsibilities of hospitals and the role of the state.
Under British law, it is common for courts to intervene when parents and doctors disagree on the treatment of a child. In such cases, the rights of the child take primacy over the parents' right to decide what's best for their offspring.
Top Comment
Shasti Brata
1789 days ago
Sad. What is also to be noted is that medical care in the UK is essentially free. The parents who are fighting so hard to keep the baby on ventilator would also have to consider if they would want to continue the fight if it were that they were paying for the treatment. In any case, it is a sad decision to go through.Read allPost comment
Popular from World
- Elon Musk's one-word take on alarming population decline in India and China
- Despite 45% pay cut, UK's richest woman earns 150 million pounds
- 'Oh Canada’: Trump shares map with 51 US states
- Who is Anita Anand, the Indo-Canadian minister in race to replace Justin Trudeau as PM
- Top 10 richest people in the world 2025 including Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg and more
end of article
Trending Stories
- Elon Musk's one-word take on alarming population decline in India and China
- “I wasn't at my best”: Former NBA Champion Derek Fisher candidly accepts blame for Allen Iverson's historic stepover on Tyronn Lue
- How did ex-Orioles star Brian Matusz die? Exploring former Pitcher’s cause of unexpected death
- Elon Musk a 'monster': Giorgia Meloni slams labelling, says because he chose the side considered "wrong" of the ...
- UnitedHealth’s secret to billions in extra medicare funds: How doctors inflate sickness scores, reveals report
- Elon Musk to Canada's outgoing PM Justin Trudeau: Girl, you’re not the ....
- Rachel Bush, Wife of Jordan Poyer, Shares Strong Opinions on Florida’s Viral 'Squatter' Arrest and Praises Josh Allen's Work Ethic
Visual Stories
- 9 foods to keep your kidneys healthy
- 10 best reasons to visit Kanha National Park right now
- 8 ways to reduce uric acid in your body
- 10 breakfast dishes that can be made with banana
- 10 indoor plants that will be in trend in 2025 (stock them now!)
UP NEXT