Continue on TOI App
Open App
TOI+

Why Ground Troops in Iran Could Be America’s Biggest Mistake

TOI.in / Mar 04, 2026, 17.58 PM IST

In this episode of The Daily Brief by DefenceHQ, Major Gaurav Arya is joined by Lt. Gen. Rakesh Sharma to examine the escalating US–Israel war against Iran and the implications of potential American “boots on the ground.” The discussion interrogates the absence of a clearly defined political end state, the limits of regime-change doctrine post-1945, and the operational realities of inserting ground forces into a vast civilisational state like Iran. They analyse the layered power structure of the Iranian system, the entrenched role of the IRGC, and why expectations of an internal uprising may have been misplaced. The episode also explores the logistical and technological challenges — from interceptor exhaustion to drone and missile saturation of Gulf airbases. Finally, they discuss the September 2025 Saudi–Pakistan defence pact, questioning whether Islamabad — amid TTP threats, Afghan instability, and domestic unrest — is realistically positioned to honour a NATO-style collective defence clause if Saudi Arabia remains under Iranian attack.0:00 – 01:18 | Introduction: Middle East on EdgeOverview of the escalating US–Israel confrontation with Iran and the emerging debate on American ground intervention.01:19 – 03:56 | What Is the Strategic Aim?Dissection of Washington’s stated objectives — existential threat, nuclear rollback, or regime change — and the absence of a clearly articulated end state.03:57 – 06:10 | Boots on Ground: Easier In Than OutWhy modern wars since 1945 show that inserting troops does not guarantee regime change or stable outcomes.06:11 – 08:58 | Can Regime Change Work in Iran?Iran’s layered governance model, succession planning, and the embedded strength of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).08:59 – 12:30 | Operational Reality: Airfields, Interceptors & Drone SaturationLogistical burdens of ground deployment, missile interception ratios, Gulf airbase vulnerability, and the scale of force required for a land campaign.12:31 – 14:49 | Saudi Arabia Under FireMissile and drone attacks on Saudi infrastructure and the regional escalation dynamic across the Gulf.14:50 – 16:11 | Saudi–Pakistan Defence Pact: Clause vs CapabilityAssessment of the September 2025 pact, Pakistan’s internal security pressures (TTP, Afghan frontier instability), domestic unrest, and whether Islamabad can realistically execute its collective defence commitment at this juncture.

03:09
Uttarakhand: Heavy rains cause massive destruction in Pipalkoti, roads and buildings damaged
03:22
Temple tragedy: At least 9 killed as temple in Shimla collapses due to heavy rainfall
02:25
Security beefed up in Delhi ahead of Independence Day
03:02
Doda's iconic Ganpat Bridge illuminated with Tricolour splendor to celebrate Independence Day
04:33
Watch: Waterlogging in Chennai following heavy rains
03:47
Mumbai-Ahmedabad bullet train project: SC dismisses plea by Godrej & Boyce challenging Bombay HC order on land acquisition
01:26
Anand Dighe's home is Shiv Sena's new central office
03:58
Freebies galore in poll-bound Karnataka: Congress promises 10kg free rice to all BPL families, if voted to power
06:41
Ahead of Standing Committee polls, AAP Councillor Pawan Sehrawat joins BJP
07:47
Need collective work to meet global challenged like climate change and high debt levels: PM Modi
08:54
India & Trump's Russian Oil Trade Claims CLASH | 'Energy Security Of 1.4 Bn Supreme Priority'
10:22
Budget 2026: Indian FM’s Huge Income Tax Announcement | Latest Slabs, Old & New Regime Rates
44:07
'Delhi NOT Most Polluted': Doctor's Shocking Reveal On Toxic Monster; And How To Fight Back
04:37
PM Modi's Big Declaration In 1st Visit To J&K After Pahalgam Attack | 'Pak Attacked Kashmiriyat'
04:08
Sikkim: Landslide Hits Indian Army Camp After River Teesta Swells; 3 Personnel Killed, 6 Missing
09:15
FULL SPEECH: Tharoor Mocks Pak's Kashmir 'Dream' In Guyana | 'They Want Something They Don't Have'
06:36
PM Modi's Shocking New Op Sindoor Reveal | '9 Terror Hideouts In Pak Destroyed In Just 22 Mins'
03:20
Indian Air Force Flaunts Rafale, BrahMos In 1st Video After Decimating Pak Airbases In Op Sindoor
04:26
Indian Army Shares 1st Video Of Missiles, Russian S-400 In Action During Op Sindoor Against Pak
04:04
India's Ballistic Missiles Spook Munir; Pak Army HQ To Be Moved After Nur Khan Base Attack | Report
ET Now Live
Zoom TV Live
Mirror Now Live
Times Now Live
03:18
Shocking! Lawyer rams Mercedes car into Kachori shop in Delhi, Six injured
03:16
Telangana cop punched, dragged by villagers, video goes viral
03:08
On Cam: Crane drags car with senior citizens sitting inside, case registered | video goes viral
03:18
Instagram influencer shot dead by husband in Rajasthan's Phalodi
03:16
CCTV: Thieves arrive in car, decamp with jewellery in MP's Damoh
03:13
Goons hurl abuses at toll plaza employee in MP's Chhatarpur
03:12
Viral: Cobra blocks road in MP's Chhatarpur district
03:15
Nigeria: Lion kills zookeeper at Obafemi Awolowo University
03:17
CCTV: Biker crushed to death by speeding bus in Madhya Pradesh's Ujjain district
03:03
Four women steal tray full of earrings from a jewellery shop in MP's Raisen