Why Myles Garrett’s trade request was never about money, despite his big Browns extension

When Myles Garrett made it clear earlier this year that he wanted out of Cleveland, few expected him to stay put—let alone become the highest-paid non-quarterback in the NFL. After a whirlwind of public trade requests, rumors, and speculation, Garrett has now inked a staggering four-year, $204.7 million contract extension with the Browns. The deal not only makes his future with the franchise through 2030 but also includes a no-trade clause, proving that when it comes to the NFL, money truly speaks louder than words.

Back in February, Myles Garrett’s trade request dominated headlines. He had expressed a deep frustration with the Browns' inability to compete at the highest level, emphasizing, “This is all about football. It’s not about money or attaining another contract. I just want to play meaningful football at the end of the year, be playing into January & into February & having that feeling of holding that trophy.” With his desire to chase a Super Bowl, many expected him to land with a contender like the Ravens, Dolphins, or Eagles.

However, just weeks after making his case for an exit, Garrett reversed course in dramatic fashion. The Browns, unwilling to part ways with their defensive cornerstone, never seriously entertained trade talks, despite multiple teams expressing interest. Seeing the franchise’s commitment, Garrett’s agent, Nicole Lynn, stepped in for discussions last week, ultimately securing a deal that pays him an unprecedented $40 million per season, with nearly $123 million in guaranteed money.
For the Browns, retaining Garrett is a monumental win. Losing their best defensive player would have been a massive setback for a team still trying to find consistent success. Garrett, who has led the league with 44 sacks over the past three seasons, is not just a statistical leader—he is a force in the locker room and a presence in the Cleveland community. His decision to stay provides a foundation for the Browns’ future, even as they continue their long road toward legitimate Super Bowl contention.
However, this extension also sends shockwaves through the NFL’s contract market. Just days ago, Maxx Crosby briefly held the title of highest-paid non-quarterback after signing a deal worth $35.5 million annually. Garrett shattered that mark, setting a new standard for elite edge rushers. Now, teams like the Dallas Cowboys, who are negotiating an extension for Micah Parsons, will feel the ripple effect.

While the payday is unquestionable, Garrett’s legacy now faces scrutiny. If winning a Super Bowl was truly his priority, staying with a team that has had just two winning seasons since 2008 seems like a contradiction. He has committed his prime years to a franchise still searching for consistent success, and with no more trade demands in his pocket, his future is now fully tied to Cleveland.
Also Read: "I am covered by God": Odell Beckham Jr. responds to assault allegations after being named in Diddy’s legal case
Whether this decision cements him as a Browns legend or a star who prioritized financial security over a championship chase remains to be seen and in the meantime, what is that one certain thing? —Myles Garrett got his price, and now the pressure is on him to deliver.