“My fiancé has never done been on that app" - New York Yankees star Jazz Chisholm Jr. shuts down obscene Ahnalys Santiago rumors after engagement

Jazz Chisholm Jr. expected his Christmas engagement to be a quiet personal milestone. Instead, the New York Yankees infielder spent part of his offseason responding to rumors that took over social media within hours.

The claims centered on his fiancée, Ahnalys Santiago, and suggested she ran an account on a rather dubious website. Chisholm chose not to stay silent. He addressed the speculation himself and shut it down directly.

How Jazz Chisholm Jr's Christmas Proposal Went Viral

Jazz Chisholm Jr proposed to Ahnalys Santiago on December 25, 2025, while the couple was vacationing in Finland. He popped the question under the Northern Lights during a snowy trip that quickly drew attention online.

Santiago shared photos of her oval-cut diamond ring on Instagram and wrote, “I’m not Da Gurl anymore yallllll I’m DA WIFEEEEEEEE.” She later said Chisholm had completely surprised her, admitting he had tricked her into thinking nothing special was planned.



Images of Chisholm kneeling in Louis Vuitton scarves spread quickly. Yankees fans congratulated him, with some joking about extending his contract after his 30-home run, 30-steal season.

How the Online Rumors About Jazz Chisholm Jr's Fiance Started

Before the engagement became public, the couple posted lighthearted Christmas Eve content. This included Grinch-themed outfits and spa clips. A viral video followed, and users on X and Reddit began digging into Ahnalys Santiago’s online presence.

After the engagement announcement, the tone shifted. Some posts claimed Santiago had an account on the website and labeled her a “model.” Others mocked Chisholm with comments like, “You will be broke in 5 years.” Rival fans joined in, while some users pushed back and pointed out racist undertones in the criticism.

Jazz Chisholm Jr's Blunt Response

Chisholm jumped into the conversation himself. He replied to posts on X and stated clearly, “My fiancé has never done such a thing.” When the rumors continued, he added sarcasm, writing, “But maybe your mom did check on her right quick.”



He accused certain accounts of “scamming” people with fake profiles and pushed back at users criticizing him for “wifing up.” Santiago also responded in her own way, posting a video and joking that she runs the house.

As notifications piled up, Chisholm joked that his fiancée was “banning” him from social media because of the constant alerts.

Fan Reaction and What It Says

Many Yankees fans rallied around the couple and focused on the engagement rather than the rumors. Others debated why athletes’ partners are often targeted online and compared the situation to similar stories across pro sports.

Chisholm, who remains under contract through 2026, closed the season reflecting on playoff lessons while navigating an unusually loud offseason. The episode showed how quickly private moments can turn public-and how firmly he chose to defend his future wife.

Get the latest WPL 2026 updates including WPL teams, full WPL 2026 schedule, and live scores for Mumbai Indians, Royal Challengers Bengaluru, UP Warriorz, Gujarat Giants, and Delhi Capitals. Also check the latest WPL Orange Cap and Purple Cap standings.