All-Time Indian Batting Greats: Former cricketer stirs debate; says 'Rohit Sharma does not quite make it there'
NEW DELHI: Former India cricketer Sanjay Manjrekar has sparked a heated debate in the cricket fraternity after declaring that ODI skipper Rohit Sharma does not belong in the pantheon of India’s all-time batting greats.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
Speaking on The Great Indian Cricket Show on Doordarshan, Manjrekar drew a sharp line between the “true legends” and the current captain. “Rohit Sharma does not fit in the All-Time Indian Batting Great list because we’re talking about legends like Gavaskar (Sunil), Tendulkar (Sachin), Dravid (Rahul), and Virat (Kohli). Rohit does not quite make it there,” Manjrekar stated.
The former batter, however, was quick to add that Rohit’s legacy lies in his selflessness and leadership, particularly in the ODI format. “But if you look at one-day cricket, selflessness, or captainship, then you have to mention Rohit Sharma. Especially after the 2023 World Cup, the love people have for him is on another level. People saw that he was never thinking about himself; he was willing to sacrifice his own interests for the team’s advantage. That’s his real speciality,” he added.
Rohit’s World Cup record certainly strengthens his case. With 1,575 runs in 28 matches at an average of 60.57, including seven centuries, he is India’s third-highest scorer in tournament history. His five centuries at the 2019 World Cup remain unmatched, while in 2023 he piled up 597 runs at a strike rate above 125, redefining aggressive starts in ODI cricket.
Across formats, Rohit’s numbers are staggering. He has 19,700 international runs, including 11,168 in ODIs with 32 hundreds and a record three double centuries. In Tests, he scored 4,301 runs with 12 centuries, and in T20Is, he leads the charts with 4,231 runs, five centuries and 205 sixes — the most by any batter.
Manjrekar, though, insisted that Test cricket carries the heaviest weight in defining greatness. “His easy domination in limited-overs cricket was always pleasing, almost making 300 runs in one ODI innings. But when you talk of an all-time Indian batting great, Test cricket holds more weightage. I don’t think he made a big impact in that format,” he concluded.
Rohit, who retired from Test cricket in May and T20Is after India’s 2024 World Cup triumph, continues to lead the ODI side.
Catch Lovlina Borgohain's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 5. Watch Here
Speaking on The Great Indian Cricket Show on Doordarshan, Manjrekar drew a sharp line between the “true legends” and the current captain. “Rohit Sharma does not fit in the All-Time Indian Batting Great list because we’re talking about legends like Gavaskar (Sunil), Tendulkar (Sachin), Dravid (Rahul), and Virat (Kohli). Rohit does not quite make it there,” Manjrekar stated.
The former batter, however, was quick to add that Rohit’s legacy lies in his selflessness and leadership, particularly in the ODI format. “But if you look at one-day cricket, selflessness, or captainship, then you have to mention Rohit Sharma. Especially after the 2023 World Cup, the love people have for him is on another level. People saw that he was never thinking about himself; he was willing to sacrifice his own interests for the team’s advantage. That’s his real speciality,” he added.
Rohit’s World Cup record certainly strengthens his case. With 1,575 runs in 28 matches at an average of 60.57, including seven centuries, he is India’s third-highest scorer in tournament history. His five centuries at the 2019 World Cup remain unmatched, while in 2023 he piled up 597 runs at a strike rate above 125, redefining aggressive starts in ODI cricket.
Manjrekar, though, insisted that Test cricket carries the heaviest weight in defining greatness. “His easy domination in limited-overs cricket was always pleasing, almost making 300 runs in one ODI innings. But when you talk of an all-time Indian batting great, Test cricket holds more weightage. I don’t think he made a big impact in that format,” he concluded.
Rohit, who retired from Test cricket in May and T20Is after India’s 2024 World Cup triumph, continues to lead the ODI side.
Catch Lovlina Borgohain's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 5. Watch Here
Popular from Sports
- Phillies Karen identified and fired after taking Harrison Bader home run ball from Drew Feltwell’s son
- CAFA Nations Cup: India create history on debut! Podium finish after dramatic shootout win over Oman
- Who is Phillies Karen? The fan who left with Harrison Bader’s ball but woke up with America against her
- Phillies dad reveals why he handed Harrison Bader home run ball to Cheryl Richardson Wagner who yelled at his son
- Phillies Karen clash revisited as family shares shocking details of Harrison Bader home run fight
end of article
Featured in sports
- India begin transition with new faces as Asia Cup returns to UAE
- Gukesh's biggest defeat? How American GM Mishra aced the battle of youngest chess icons
- When MS Dhoni was compared to legendary West Indian Gary Sobers
- India's likely playing XI vs UAE: Jitesh in, Sanju out; no Kuldeep
- Asia Cup vs IPL, WC, Champions Trophy: Which has highest prize money?
- Asia Cup today: Afghanistan vs Hong Kong gets tournament underway
International Sports
- Kevin O’Connell shows coaching genius with subtle yet game-changing decision in Vikings’ win over Chicago Bears
- Vikings’ comeback triumph marred by injury concerns: Kevin O’Connell opens up on Blake Cashman and Jeff Okudah’s condition
- NFL Results today: Vikings vs. Bears full Week 1 highlights, scores, and top players
- “Average a*s receiver”: Rex Ryan blasts Jaguars for mishandling Travis Hunter in his first NFL game
- J.J. McCarthy clinches first NFL victory as rookie QB leads Vikings to thrilling 27–24 win over Bears in primetime debut
Trending Stories
- Phillies Karen identified and fired after taking Harrison Bader home run ball from Drew Feltwell’s son
- Arunachal Pradesh records first-ever photographic evidence of the elusive Pallas’s cat
- Asia Cup 2025 Schedule: Full Fixtures, Match Dates, Venues, Time and Where to Watch Live
- Who is Phillies Karen? The fan who left with Harrison Bader’s ball but woke up with America against her
- US shuts down third-country visa option, forcing Indian students into backlogs and tougher interviews at home
- Nepal lifts social media ban after 19 die in Gen Z protests
- 'How was he hired': Florida crash truck driver Harjinder Singh's employer subpoenaed, asked to provide all documents
Photostories
- US ends third-country visa stamping: What it means and the changes travellers can expect
- 5 ways technology is secretly shaping your memory-And how to use it for your benefit
- Bollywood beauties and their alleged affairs with the underworld
- 10 high-protein nuts and seeds (and how to eat them)
- Heart health: Nitrate-rich vegetables lower cardiovascular disease risk by 12%, natural food sources to know
- 6 Hindu temples where non-veg is offered as prasad
- Why do churches ring bells at specific hours (Angelus), not just during services
- Fatty Liver disease: 5 supplements that can help reverse the condition in 3 months
- How to lower blood pressure: 10 lifestyle changes from the latest US guidelines
- 7 cool hill stations just a drive away from Chennai
Top Trends
Up Next
Start a Conversation
Post comment