IND vs ENG | 'He has only himself to blame': Rishabh Pant's reckless shot sparks debate
NEW DELHI: India’s Rishabh Pant suffered a foot fracture during the ongoing Manchester Test against England after attempting a reverse sweep on Day 1. The injury occurred when he was on 37, as Chris Woakes delivered a yorker that struck Pant’s right toe, reportedly causing the fracture.
Despite the setback, Pant resumed his innings on Day 2 and battled through the pain to notch up a gritty half-century before falling to Jofra Archer. His injury has now cast doubt over his availability for India’s second innings and reignited conversations around the use of injury substitutes in Test cricket.
Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
Former England captain Geoffrey Boycott, speaking on The Telegraph Podcast, criticised Pant’s shot selection and said the injury was avoidable.
“It is always sad when a player gets hurt and affects his ability to play a part in the game—especially someone as talented as him. But he has only himself to blame,” Boycott said.
“They were nicely in control, batting orthodox—there was no need to try something outrageous. Rishabh tries amazing strokes. When they come off, people are astonished and cheer him, and that is the essence of his batting. But when they don’t, it can look silly. India were building a strong position. Some might say that’s just his nature, but if he can’t bat in both innings, it might cost India the match. He’s that important,” he added.
The incident has sparked fresh debate over allowing like-for-like substitutions in Tests.
Speaking to TalkSport Cricket, former England batter David Lloyd offered his take: “I’m probably against runners, but I’m in favour of substitutes for external injuries. It does open a can of worms, but if it’s a break and medically he’s out for six weeks, then maybe a like-for-like replacement is worth considering. Not something like replacing a batter with a spinner, though.”
For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Despite the setback, Pant resumed his innings on Day 2 and battled through the pain to notch up a gritty half-century before falling to Jofra Archer. His injury has now cast doubt over his availability for India’s second innings and reignited conversations around the use of injury substitutes in Test cricket.
Former England captain Geoffrey Boycott, speaking on The Telegraph Podcast, criticised Pant’s shot selection and said the injury was avoidable.
“It is always sad when a player gets hurt and affects his ability to play a part in the game—especially someone as talented as him. But he has only himself to blame,” Boycott said.
“They were nicely in control, batting orthodox—there was no need to try something outrageous. Rishabh tries amazing strokes. When they come off, people are astonished and cheer him, and that is the essence of his batting. But when they don’t, it can look silly. India were building a strong position. Some might say that’s just his nature, but if he can’t bat in both innings, it might cost India the match. He’s that important,” he added.
The incident has sparked fresh debate over allowing like-for-like substitutions in Tests.
Speaking to TalkSport Cricket, former England batter David Lloyd offered his take: “I’m probably against runners, but I’m in favour of substitutes for external injuries. It does open a can of worms, but if it’s a break and medically he’s out for six weeks, then maybe a like-for-like replacement is worth considering. Not something like replacing a batter with a spinner, though.”
For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here.
Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
Top Comment
A
Amit Bhagwati
14 hours ago
Mr Boycott you are a respected ex-cricketer and also one of my favorite commentator but a request to you. if you do not understand current day test cricket please do not comment on it. And make a fun of yourself. You were a fine cricketer of old generation. Also as a commentator u were great in Sourav ganguly era. But this are different times so please don't give your views now and make a fun of yourself.Read allPost comment
Popular from Sports
- IND vs ENG: History for KL Rahul! India batter becomes first-ever opener in 46 years to ...
- “My body failed me”: Dwyane Wade’s wife Gabrielle Union opens up about facing “public humiliation” after choosing surrogacy
- IND vs ENG, 4th Test: Will Rishabh Pant bat on Day 5? India batting coach Shitanshu Kotak shares latest updates
- IND vs ENG Test | 'If you can’t play the short ball, go play tennis or golf': Sunil Gavaskar questions ICC’s concussion substitute rule
- From 0/2 to hope renewed: Shubman Gill, KL Rahul rewrite a doomed script at Old Trafford
end of article
Featured in sports
- From 0/2 to hope renewed: Shubman Gill, KL Rahul rewrite a doomed script at Old Trafford
- 'If you don't play bilateral, don't play tournaments too': Azhar on India vs Pak clash
- Chess | WC Final: Divya lets advantage slip, holds Humpy to draw
- IND vs ENG: Will Pant bat on Day 5? India coach Kotak shares latest updates
- India batting coach Sitanshu Kotak opens lid on Karun Nair being dropped
- 'We’re hoping he’ll bowl tomorrow' – Eng batting coach gives update on Stokes’ fitness
International Sports
- Brandon Aiyuk’s wife reveals why NFL wives panic as training camp kicks off with intense uncertainty
- What’s the real reason behind Travis Kelce’s sudden Taylor Swift photo dump on Instagram?
- “Obsessed ex”: Gisele Bündchen blasted for allegedly stalking Tom Brady near his Miami mansion
- Matty Healy's mother thrashed Taylor Swift for her lyrics as Travis Kelce hard launches their relationship on Instagram
- “He outplayed Patrick Mahomes”: Cris Carter defends Jalen Hurts after Cam Newton snub
Trending Stories
- Ciara and baby Amora twin in new adorable photo as fans gush over Russell Wilson's lookalike daughter
- Chess WC Final Live: Divya, Humpy share honours in Game 1 draw
- Shannon Sharpe’s $50M settlement twists as ex-girlfriend steps in
- Asia Cup 2025 schedule: Complete fixtures, India vs Pakistan date out
- IND vs ENG Live: Shubman Gill, KL Rahul power India to 174/2 at stumps
- Jeff Bezos sells $1.5 billion worth of Amazon shares, now holds stock valued at…
- Toddler bites cobra to death, lives to tell tale
Photostories
- 5 crop top ideas to steal from Bollywood beauties
- 7 hidden reasons why adding 'moringa' to our diet can help us detox our lungs, kidneys and reduce cortisol levels naturally
- Exclusive - Bharti Singh opens up on Laughter Chefs 2's success, memories of Sidharth Shukla, and wish to reunite with Kapil Sharma and Krushna for a stand-up show
- From Maldives to Seychelles, here are 10 island nations perfect for honeymooners
- From cricketer Rishabh Pant recalling his horrific accident to Aaryamann making girlfriend Yogita meet parents: Archana Puran Singh shares candid moments
- Evenings by the Ganga: 5 Ghats in India To Witness Grand Ganga Aarti Ceremony
- India salutes Kargil War bravehearts; commemorates 26 years of victory in Operation Vijay - In pics
- How Nirupa Roy became Bollywood’s 'Queen of Misery'—But her real life was quite the opposite
- Laughter Chefs 2 Grand Finale: When and where to watch, what to expect and more;all you need to know
- Alanna to Ahaan Panday: Meet the stylish Panday siblings of B-town
Top Trends
Up Next