NEW DELHI: After England secured a 28-run victory over India in the first Test at the Rajiv Gandhi International Stadium in Hyderabad, former England spinner
Monty Panesar remarked that
Rohit Sharma appeared 'clueless.'
Discussing the performances of
Ollie Pope and Tom Hartley, he commented that if these two English cricketers maintain their form, then the visitors stand a chance of winning the series with a 5-0 margin.
"If Ollie Pope and Tom Hartley continue to play like this it will be a whitewash, it will be 5-0 for England. It can happen if Ollie Pope and Tom Hartley play like this," Panesar told ANI.
Monty emphasised the significance of England's unexpected win, expressing that it was a very "big" achievement that took many by surprise.
Panesar suggested that the hosts should curtail the freedom given to the English players to improve their performance.
The former England spinner also speculated that if Virat Kohli was part of the team, he would have charged against the visitors.
Panesar added that England might still play with the fear of failure in the upcoming four Test matches.
India vs England 1st Test: Statistical Highlights
"It is a very big victory, no one even imagined this was even possible. Everyone thought that England would lose after a 190 deficit but Ollie Pope had a brilliant inning one of the best innings we have seen in a long time and Rohit Sharma was clueless," Monty said.
"India need to stop giving the freedom that the England players are getting. If Virat Kohli was playing he would have been in the faces of these England players and told them 'Hey, do it again let's see how good you are'. This is an England team who are not scared of losing, they don't scare if they lose. In the next four games, they (England) would still play with the fear of failure."
Additionally, he expressed that England's 28-run victory in the first Test against India felt akin to winning the World Cup.
"It was one of the most famous victories England have ever produced overseas. This is a big news in England. It feels like we have won the World Cup," he added.
The 41-year-old added that the England team are learning from India by seeing the "bowlers ball, they watch how they bat and their body language". He further added that the English squad looked at India's weaknesses and then they understood how they beat the hosts.
He pointed out how Ben Stokes backed Tom Hartley even after a sloppy performance in the first inning and later the English spinner shined in the second inning.
"I think England is a team who are learning from India, they watch India, they see how the bowlers ball, they watch how they bat and their body language. They look at any weakness in the Indian team and then they start understanding that they can beat India. I will give you an example, Axar Patel was not mentally tough and dropped catches. On the other hand, look at Tom Hartley, in the first inning Yashasvi Jaiswal smashed him so many fours but Ben Stokes backed him, his captaincy was brilliant and Hartley's second-inning bowling performance was brilliant," he added.
The former cricketer said that Ben Stokes' side's approach is different, adding that the visitors would learn from Rohit Sharma's side and would beat them "fearlessly".
"This England team's approach is totally different. They will look at India and learn from them and will beat them and they are playing fearlessly," he added.
When asked if Ravindra Jadeja and KL Rahul's injuries would affect India's performance in the second Test match, Monty said that now "Rohit Sharma can show his true captaincy". He also asked the Indian skipper to show some fight.
"I think it makes it easier for Rohit Sharma now. Rohit Sharma will say that they need to play fearlessly. Now Rohit Sharma can show his true captaincy. He needs to show that they won't get down after losing the first Test match. C'mon, Rohit Sharma show some fight," he added.
The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) on Monday announced that Ravindra Jadeja and KL Rahul have been ruled out of the second Test match against England due to injuries.
Jadeja sustained a hamstring injury during play on Day 4 of the first Test in Hyderabad. Meanwhile, Rahul complained of right quadriceps pain.
While concluding, he added that Kohli's "presence and intensity" is missing from the India team. He added that Rohit needs to prove himself now that he can turn around the series without Kohli.
"Virat Kohli has that presence and intensity, which is missing currently in the India team. Virat Kohli has that aura and presence. If England win the next Test match then India will be in big trouble. This is a big moment for Rohit Sharma, he needs to show that he can turn around the match without Virat Kohli," he added.
(With inputs from ANI)Get the latest ICC Men’s T20 World Cup 2026 updates, including the full schedule, teams, live scores, points table, and key series stats such as top run-scorers and wicket-takers.