Egg vs paneer vs soya vs chicken: Which is a better source of protein for breakfast

Breakfast is said to be the most important meal of the day. As per nutritionist Rujuta Diwekar, skipping breakfast is not a healthy practice. It often leads to consuming more calories later in the day. And when we talk about breakfast, a rich source of protein is inevitable. Wondering why? Protein is the building block of the human body.It is said that the human body needs enough protein to build, repair, and maintain tissues such as muscles, skin, and organs. It also supports the production of enzymes, hormones, and antibodies, which are essential for immunity and overall functioning. Protein also helps improve strength, supports weight management by keeping you full for longer, and promotes healthy aging by preventing muscle loss. Hence, it is important to add rich sources of protein to the daily diet. According to the British Heart Foundation, most adults need around 0.75 g of protein per kilo of body weight per day (for the average woman, this is 45 g, or 55 g for men). This piece of information explores a comparison between egg, paneer, soya, and chicken as rich sources of protein and which is a better one for breakfast.

Protein: 6 g per eggBenefits: As per experts, eggs are often considered a “complete protein” because they contain all nine essential amino acids in the right proportion. The study titled Health Functions of Egg Protein states that egg protein is a remarkably abundant source of protein, with an amino acid score of 100 and the highest net protein utilization rate. It is also said that it contains approximately the same amount of branched-chain amino acids as milk protein. It also has more sulfur-containing amino acids than other protein sources. The amino acid score for EWP is 100, and its net protein utilization is reported to be higher than that of whey protein. Proteins are also present in eggshell membranes. It is mentioned that egg white is a good source of protein that can be utilized to increase body protein, i.e., muscle mass. Overall, eggs provide a nutrient-dense, bioavailable protein source that supports metabolic health, muscle function, and antioxidant defense. They improve muscle mass and have muscle-strengthening and antifatigue effects when consumed during exercise; they can improve lipid metabolism by reducing visceral fat and lowering serum cholesterol levels. The intake of egg protein may, thus, contribute to the prevention of physical frailty and metabolic syndrome.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9368041/

Protein: 18-20 g per 100 gmsBenefits: It is said that paneer is an excellent choice for breakfast as it is packed with high-quality protein, essential for muscle growth and sustained energy throughout the day. Its slow-digesting nature keeps you full for longer, reducing cravings and aiding in weight loss and management. It is rich in calcium and phosphorus that help with strengthening bones and teeth, making it a great option for all age groups. It also contains healthy fats that provide steady energy without spiking blood sugar levels, making it ideal for diabetics. Additionally, paneer is easy to digest and versatile, allowing you to prepare a variety of nutritious dishes like paneer bhurji, stuffed parathas, or salads for a wholesome and delicious start to the day. According to a study titled Paneer—An Indian soft cheese variant: a review, paneer has a fairly high level of fat (22–25%) and protein (16–18%) and a low level of lactose (2.0–2.7%). Paneer is of great value in diet, especially in the Indian vegetarian context, because it contains a fairly high level of fat and proteins as well as some minerals, especially calcium and phosphorus. It is also a good source of fat soluble vitamins A and D. So its food and nutritive value is fairly high.

Protein: 52 g per 100 gBenefits: As per a study titled A review on plant-based proteins from soybean: Health benefits and soy product development, soy protein is a high-quality protein with a protein digestibility-corrected amino acid score (PDCAAS) of 1.00, which is close to some of the proteins from animal sources, such as meat and dairy. Soy proteins contain well-balanced essential amino acids except for sulfur-containing ones like methionine. Another study states that for most healthy adults, including soy several times per week or even daily is considered safe, with individual considerations for thyroid disease, certain hormone‑sensitive cancers, or specific allergies best discussed with a healthcare professional.

Protein: 27 g per 100 gBenefits: As per experts, chicken provides all nine essential amino acids in favorable proportions, making it a “complete” protein useful for maintaining and building lean body mass. A PMC study on different chicken parts and cooking methods states that protein and essential amino acid retention remains high (generally above about 80–90%), with roasted or steamed breast retaining particularly good protein and amino acid levels. Chicken is also said to be low on fat, rich in B vitamins and selenium, which makes it ideal for muscle recovery after workouts.

From the above analysis, if you are keen on muscle building chicken anf eggs can be your go to food. And for vegetarians, paneer and soya are the best choices. For weight loss, eggs and soya are ideal and for heart health, soya and chicken in the form of grilled and boiled make for ideal choices.
In a nutshell, if you are a non-vegetarian, eggs and chicken are the most bioavailable protein and for vegetarians, paneer and soya together make for an excellent amino acid balance. Ideally, it is best to rotate all four, as per your diet preference.

All Images Courtesy: istock
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article—is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered medical advice. Always consult your health practitioner before starting any routine.