'Speak to a doctor': Rajya Sabha witnesses Kharge vs Nadda over Jagdeep Dhankhar's 'sudden exit' — watch
NEW DELHI: The first day of Parliament Winter Session 2025 witnessed a Mallikarjun Kharge vs JP Nadda showdown in the Rajya Sabha over the leader of opposition's reference to "sudden exit" of former Vice President Jagdeep Dhankhar.
The sharpest moment came when leader of the House JP Nadda advised Kharge to “visit a doctor” to deal with their political frustrations, insisting the House stay focused on the agenda at hand.
The leader of opposition in the Upper House, during his welcome address to the Rajya Sabha chairman CP Radhakrishnan, brought up his predecessor's "completely unexpected and sudden exit from the office of the Chairman, Rajya Sabha."
"I hope you will not mind that I am constrained to refer to your predecessor's completely unexpected and sudden exit from the office of the Chairman, Rajya Sabha," he said amid opposition from the BJP members.
"The chairman, being custodian of the entire house, belongs as much to the opposition as to the government. I was disheartened that the house did not get an opportunity to bid him a farewell. Regardless, wish him, on behalf of the entire opposition, a very healthy life," Kharge said.
The statement did not go down well with the leader of house JP Nadda who called the remarks "irrelevant".
"We must maintain the dignity of the felicitation program, and it would be good if we discuss it accordingly. If we start discussing the issue that our Leader of the Opposition brought up today, the farewell, and all the other topics, I think it's irrelevant," he said.
"There will also be discussions from here that you moved a no-confidence motion against him, not once but twice...I think our Leader of the Opposition is very respectable. The defeat in Bihar, Haryana, and Maharashtra has caused you considerable pain. But you should express your pain and suffering to a doctor. You should speak to a doctor when the time comes," he added.
Earlier this year, Dhankhar’s abrupt resignation as Vice President, officially citing health reasons with two years still left in his term, had triggered a flurry of speculation and conspiracy theories across political circles.
His decision, announced on the very first day of Parliament’s Monsoon Session, was highly unusual—making him only the third Vice President after VV Giri and R Venkataraman to step down before completing a full tenure.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
The leader of opposition in the Upper House, during his welcome address to the Rajya Sabha chairman CP Radhakrishnan, brought up his predecessor's "completely unexpected and sudden exit from the office of the Chairman, Rajya Sabha."
"I hope you will not mind that I am constrained to refer to your predecessor's completely unexpected and sudden exit from the office of the Chairman, Rajya Sabha," he said amid opposition from the BJP members.
"The chairman, being custodian of the entire house, belongs as much to the opposition as to the government. I was disheartened that the house did not get an opportunity to bid him a farewell. Regardless, wish him, on behalf of the entire opposition, a very healthy life," Kharge said.
The statement did not go down well with the leader of house JP Nadda who called the remarks "irrelevant".
"There will also be discussions from here that you moved a no-confidence motion against him, not once but twice...I think our Leader of the Opposition is very respectable. The defeat in Bihar, Haryana, and Maharashtra has caused you considerable pain. But you should express your pain and suffering to a doctor. You should speak to a doctor when the time comes," he added.
Earlier this year, Dhankhar’s abrupt resignation as Vice President, officially citing health reasons with two years still left in his term, had triggered a flurry of speculation and conspiracy theories across political circles.
His decision, announced on the very first day of Parliament’s Monsoon Session, was highly unusual—making him only the third Vice President after VV Giri and R Venkataraman to step down before completing a full tenure.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
Top Comment
V
Venkatesan G V Advocate
6 hours ago
The now defunct and rejected by people opposition particularly the "con"gress trying to create controversy by digging skeletons out of the grave and make it an issue. Now, it has to face the National Herald case and so all these nautanki. They should focus and cry for for the people's problems not the ex vp. Idiots.Read allPost comment
Popular from India
- BSF warns of 120 terrorists on LoC launch pads
- SC orders CBI probe into ‘digital arrest’ scam cases
- Asia’s arms race shift: India climbs, China slides on PLA graft charges
- Winter may be chillier with more cold waves in parts of north: IMD
- Not just money, deepfakes robbing people of dignity
end of article
Trending Stories
- ‘Stood up for women, paid with his life’: 20 men ambush & kill Haryana bodybuilder after tiff at wedding party
- Govt to back air passengers in SC against Delhi, Mumbai airport operators in Rs 50,000 crore suit
03:29 BrahMos scientist Nishant Agarwal arrested for 'passing secrets' to Pakistan cleared of charges- Leon Draisaitl breaks silence with sharp message that puts new spotlight on Connor McDavid leadership
- Cyclone Ditwah Tracker Live: Chennai airport cancels several flights; IMD warns severe threat to Tamil Nadu, Puducherry, south Andhra Pradesh
- While Drake Maye preps quietly for Giants, wife Ann’s viral gym photo brings unexpected buzz to Patriots fans
- 2025 NFL Playoff Picture: Updated AFC/NFC Standings and Teams Eliminated After Week 13
Featured in India
- India’s AIDS deaths down 81% since 2010, infections fall 49%
- PM Modi pledges aid to Sri Lanka post-Cyclone Ditwah
- Study objections of Major’s kin before clearing film: HC to CBFC
- SC refuses to grant more time for waqf detail upload on portal
- SC to decide if CAA applicants can make it to rolls under SIR
- Parl forum for delivery, not drama, says PM Modi
Photostories
- Diabetes management: Doctor shares top 5 lifestyle strategies to lower HbA1c levels
- From Sunda Pangolins to Sunda tiger: 5 of the most endangered animals in the world
- 5 statement watches for women that will complete your traditional wedding look
- Kamal Haasan performances that redefined Indian cinema forever
- Increase protein intake: 4 easy ways to add more of it to everyday diet
- 3 powerful anti-inflammatory drinks and how to make them at home
- From Dead Sea Scrolls to Hope Diamond, 7 priceless objects in the world
- 7 dinner dishes made with leftover roti offering over 20 gms protein
- 5 animals that camouflage so perfectly that they almost become invisible
- How to make fiber-rich Gobhi ka Paratha for breakfast
Videos
08:12 Watch: MPs Speak Out as SIR Row Dominates Winter Session Opening02:29 India’s Elections Earn Global Praise, CEC Calls It A ‘Moment Of Pride’ Amid Vote Row Claims03:23 Haryana Bodybuilder Killed After Standing Up To Harassers; Family Says Attack Was Planned Murder08:43 Modi Trolls Opposition Over Bihar Setback Days Before Parliament Showdown06:28 Woman Marries Boyfriend’s Corpse After Family Kills Him, Alleges Police Provoked Brother03:29 Major Twist In BrahMos Espionage Case As Higher Court Acquits Scientist Of Passing Defence Secrets04:39 Ramaphosa Praises PM Modi's Endorsement of South Africa Hosting G20 Summit, Counters Trump’s Claims04:02 ‘Is There Any Law?’ Renuka Chaudhary Sparks Row After Bringing Stray Dog to Parliament04:59 BSF IG Warns Of Looming Threat As 120 Terrorists Wait In PoK Despite Dip In Infiltration Attempts
Up Next