Sonam Wangchuk detained on 'stale' FIRs, in violation of law, wife tells SC
NEW DELHI: The wife of detained climate activist Sonam Wangchuk told Supreme Court on Wednesday that he was in no way connected with the violence that erupted in Ladakh on September 24 as he was only staging a non-violent and peaceful protest through a hunger strike and that there had been "grave and incurable procedural lapses" in his detention following the incident.
In a detailed petition filed in the court, Gitanjali Angmo pointed out various flaws in the action taken against her husband and submitted that four videos which were primarily relied upon by the detaining authority were provided to him after 23 days.
She told the court that the detention order was passed on the basis of "stale" FIRs, with three of the five FIRs being filed a year back. She said a fourth FIR was filed in Aug, but it was not connected with the incident, and the fifth FIR filed over the September 24 incident "does not contain any allegation of violence, provocation or instigation against Wangchuk". "In fact, the FIR clearly states that certain miscreants instigated people who joined the hunger strike," she said.
"It is submitted that the detention order suffers from gross illegality and arbitrariness, as it relies upon stale, irrelevant, and extraneous FIRs. Out of the five FIRs relied upon, three pertain to the year 2024, bearing no proximate, live or rational nexus to his detention in September 2025. Moreover, four out of the five FIRs, of which three are registered against 'unknown persons', do not name him. There is thus no clear, live, proximate or intelligible connection between FIRs & his preventive detention under the NSA," the petition said.
The detention order is premised on the fear of public panic which may be caused if Wangchuk is not detained, with the respondents not furnishing any evidence linking the statements made by him to any incident of public unrest or media outrage.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
She told the court that the detention order was passed on the basis of "stale" FIRs, with three of the five FIRs being filed a year back. She said a fourth FIR was filed in Aug, but it was not connected with the incident, and the fifth FIR filed over the September 24 incident "does not contain any allegation of violence, provocation or instigation against Wangchuk". "In fact, the FIR clearly states that certain miscreants instigated people who joined the hunger strike," she said.
"It is submitted that the detention order suffers from gross illegality and arbitrariness, as it relies upon stale, irrelevant, and extraneous FIRs. Out of the five FIRs relied upon, three pertain to the year 2024, bearing no proximate, live or rational nexus to his detention in September 2025. Moreover, four out of the five FIRs, of which three are registered against 'unknown persons', do not name him. There is thus no clear, live, proximate or intelligible connection between FIRs & his preventive detention under the NSA," the petition said.
The detention order is premised on the fear of public panic which may be caused if Wangchuk is not detained, with the respondents not furnishing any evidence linking the statements made by him to any incident of public unrest or media outrage.
Select The Times of India as your preferred source on Google Search
Popular from India
- Stay off district judiciary, it's our domain: Allahabad HC to Supreme Court
- Killed PIO in Canada as he didn't pay up: Bishnoi gang; brief lockdown in locality after incident
- After KYC, compulsory KYV is here. And it’s driving people up the wall
- ‘If you tell Modi to dance...’: Rahul Gandhi opens Bihar campaign with attack on PM; brings back ‘vote chori’ barb
- Myanmar scam hub crackdown: 500 Indians detained in Thailand; MEA assures repatriation
end of article
Trending Stories
- Cowboys legend Michael Irvin gets emotional about watching his wife slowly disappear to Alzheimer’s
- Stefon Diggs reportedly got Drake’s “Kiki” pregnant while expecting a baby with Cardi B
- How Connor McDavid’s wife Lauren Kyle McDavid is shaping Edmonton’s design and lifestyle culture
- Charlie Kirk’s Super Bowl rival show might be in trouble — Fans think TPUSA’s ‘All American Halftime’ is getting canceled
- Ronda Rousey and Travis Browne combined net worth in 2025: From Octagon icons to Hollywood stars
- General Motors lays off hundreds of engineers on Microsoft Teams; says: It's not your performance, it's…
- 3I/ATLAS nears Earth on 29 October 2025: Rare interstellar comet has stunned scientists with cosmic secrets; tips to watch and related FAQs
Featured in India
- In Bihar’s Jawaniya, a river runs where a village once was
- Ex-DSP shoots AAP neta in Punjab, 'on the run'
- 1.2 crore lost in digital arrest, ex-babu dies of shock
- Yes Bank-ADAG loan fraud case: Anil Ambani's son under CBI lens
- Killed PIO in Canada as he didn't pay up: Bishnoi gang; brief lockdown in locality after incident
- Stay off district judiciary, it's our domain: Allahabad HC to Supreme Court
Photostories
- Sara Ali Khan’s spiritual travel diaries reflect her deep sense of faith and wanderlust
- Tough times don’t last, strong couples do: 10 quotes to prove it
- 5 benefits of Pilates over gym and walking, and how to do it right at home
- 6 of the most beautiful octopus species in the world
- From ‘Stree’ to ‘Shanti Priya’: Iconic Bollywood Halloween costume ideas
- Princess Diana to Cleopatra: 5 legendary women in history and their signature jewellery style
- Beyond the spotlight Bollywood stars chase passions that define their true selves
- World Sandwich Day 2025: 10 types of sandwiches from across the world
- Halloween 2025 from Paris to Prague: How Europe’s old towns are embracing spooky Chic
- How buying vegetables post your morning walk can help one live longer
Videos
25:46 Bangladesh Next Afghanistan? Security Expert Warns As Yunus Woos Zakir Naik, Hafiz Aide11:32 ’They Talk, We Act’: JDU’s Bijendra Prasad Yadav Slams Tejashwi, Rubbishes Mahagathbandhan Manifesto17:49 BJP’s Neeraj Kumar Singh Exudes Confidence Of Bihar Poll Win With ‘Big Majority’ | Exclusive03:15 WATCH: Moment When Indian-Origin Businessman Darshan Singh Sahsi Killed By Bishnoi Gang In Canada06:19 India Tears Into 'Baseless Claims' on Pahalgam Attack In Myanmar Rights Briefing At United Nations03:19 President Murmu Poses With IAF Pilot Shivangi Singh Pakistan Said It Captured In Op Sindoor03:01 From Sidhu Moose Wala To Canada: Lawrence Bishnoi Gang Expands Threat To Global Punjabi Scene03:03 Diljit Dosanjh Faces Khalistani Fury: Big B Gesture Sparks Outrage Ahead of Australia Concert Show05:04 Delhi’s ₹3.2 Crore Cloud Seeding Mission Falls Flat, Experts Cite Low Moisture and Weak Clouds
Up Next
Start a Conversation
Post comment