Quitting a live-in relationship is not a criminal offence: SC
NEW DELHI: While sympathising with women whose live-in partners have walked out of the relationship, Supreme Court on Monday said courts could not do much as ending a consensual relationship was not an offence.
Hearing the plea of a woman who was in a live-in relationship for 15 years, but whose partner married someone else despite a child being born to them, a bench of Justices B V Nagarathna and Ujjal Bhuyan said it could not allow her plea for a criminal case of sexual harassment and exploitation against him, as it was a consensual relationship.
“There was a consensual relationship and a child was born. Once he walks out, it is not a criminal offence. Where is the question of an offence when the relationship was consensual?” the bench said.
The court said there was no legal binding in such a relationship and that people should be careful about the vagaries of live-in relationships.
“Why did she go and live with him before marriage? They could have married. Now she is saying sexual assault,” the bench told her lawyer. The woman’s counsel said she was an 18year-old widow when she came in contact with the man, and that she was forced into a physical relationship on the false promise of marriage. She told the bench that the man had marriedfour times.
Refusing to go into his alleged misdeeds, the bench said, “We can only sympathise with your client; she got fooled or whatever. She went with him, had a child, and lived with himfor 15 years.”
The bench said she could seek maintenance from the man for her eight-year-old child, as he was born out of that relationship. As her lawyer urged the court that mediation could be opted for to seek maintenance, the bench issued notice on that limited issue.
Get the latest updates on Election 2026 exit poll results across Assam, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, West Bengal, and Puducherry.
“There was a consensual relationship and a child was born. Once he walks out, it is not a criminal offence. Where is the question of an offence when the relationship was consensual?” the bench said.
The court said there was no legal binding in such a relationship and that people should be careful about the vagaries of live-in relationships.
“Why did she go and live with him before marriage? They could have married. Now she is saying sexual assault,” the bench told her lawyer. The woman’s counsel said she was an 18year-old widow when she came in contact with the man, and that she was forced into a physical relationship on the false promise of marriage. She told the bench that the man had marriedfour times.
Refusing to go into his alleged misdeeds, the bench said, “We can only sympathise with your client; she got fooled or whatever. She went with him, had a child, and lived with himfor 15 years.”
The bench said she could seek maintenance from the man for her eight-year-old child, as he was born out of that relationship. As her lawyer urged the court that mediation could be opted for to seek maintenance, the bench issued notice on that limited issue.
Get the latest updates on Election 2026 exit poll results across Assam, Tamil Nadu, Kerala, West Bengal, and Puducherry.
Top Comment
D
Dr. Mohan R Bolla
11 hours ago
Namaste! Jurisprudencially what ought to have been justice ! Looking at the pathetic situation of the young girl widow @18,(not educated perhaps) the man luring, promising to marry exploits her vulnerable situation! She is the victim n more particularly the child is the victim! Instead of questioning the man responsible who satisfied his lust, exploitative, the system questions her as offender!? He ought to have questioned! If the live in relationship was TRUE, n the child birth is out of such relationship, justice ought to be done to her and the child! Kindly be pleased to refer to Badshah vs sou. Urmila Badshah case for just analysis n reasoning! Kindly be pleased to deal with a strong hand with a message to the exploitative men coming out of Legal technicalities....! Mediation doesn't have a strong arm!Read allPost comment
Popular from India
- Phase-1 vote surge new poll rider in TMC’s comfort zone
- Bengal turns fortress for phase-II poll: 2.3 lakh CAPF & 38,297 state cops in place
- Tribunals restore 1,468 votes in West Bengal, delete six names for second phase
- Surge in 'lone wolves' creates a 'needle in haystack' scenario for intel agencies
- 'Lone wolf' asks 2 guards their faith, stabs them
end of article
Trending Stories
- Bengal polls: 18.39% voter turnout in 2nd phase till 9am amid heavy deployment of central forces
- CG Board 12th Result 2026 Live Updates: Class 12th scorecards to be released shortly, how to download from official websites and DigiLocker, check latest updates here
- TS SSC Class 10th Result Live Updates: Telangana Class 10th results to be released shortly, how to download from Manabadi portal, DigiLocker, and Whatsapp, keep checking latest updates here
- Exit poll results 2026 for Bengal, Tamil Nadu, Assam, Kerala, Puducherry: Date, time, where, and how to watch
- Board Exam Results 2026 Live Updates: Telangana, Andhra Pradesh, Assam and CISCE results expected within April; here are the dates
- PBKS vs RR Live Score: RR hand PBKS first defeat of the season, win by 6 wickets
- US Israel Iran War News Live Updates: Trump asks aides to prepare for extended Hormuz blockade; tells King Charles Iran ‘defeated’
Featured in India
- 'This is TMC’s technique': BJP alleges party symbol 'taped' over in Bengal's Falta
- FSSAI proposes plastic-free packaging for pan masala, gutka
- NFHS-6 data likely in first half of May
- 'No vacuum in law to deal with the offence' — What Supreme Court said on hate speeches
- 'Gave clean chit to Pakistan': Congress calls Rajnath's SCO meet statement 'anti-national'
- 1 in 14 school children obese in India; north tops chart
Photostories
- 5 silent signs of vitamin deficiency you shouldn't ignore: The body speaks first
- Don’t book your flights before knowing these smart tips
- 6 benefits of drawing for child brain development, according to research
- Chef Vikas Khanna reveals the dish he makes when he misses home; recipe inside
- MS Dhoni calls this city his home: "There's no good reason for me to work, to shift to any other city"
- 10 royal baby boy names inspired by kings and warriors
- Suhana Khan returns in liquid gold in an Arpita Mehta saree that refuses to be ignored
- Morning affirmation at 5am: Feeling lost? This might help
- From tasting success and popularity after playing Samar to being ousted overnight from Anupamaa: Paras Kalnawat on his journey
- Kate Middleton dips into Princess Diana’s 1995 Germany look with sapphire earrings from the royal jewellery archives
Videos
04:15 UAE Quits OPEC In Big Oil Shake-Up: What It Means For India08:06 ‘Siddaramaiah Ready To Step Down As Karnataka CM If Rahul Gandhi Asks’: Ex-Minister Rajanna09:58 Bengal Phase 2 Polls: 142 Constituencies Vote Today, Over 3.21 Crore Voters to Decide05:04 Chokepoints of Power: how India can 'trump' China on the seas03:10 Swati Maliwal’s Explosive Exit: Assault Allegations, ‘Betrayal’ Charges Rock AAP As She Joins BJP03:10 Indian Aviation Sector Warns Of Possible Shutdown Amid Soaring Fuel Costs06:52 UNGA Chief Hails India’s Global Role, Calls India’s Leadership Central To Multilateralism03:18 India To Receive Fourth Unit Of S-400 Missile Systems From Russia, To Be Deployed In Rajasthan05:01 ISRO-s Big Shift- Civilians To Join Gaganyaan Missions - India-s Space Programme Expands
Up Next