What is Article 35A and how is it significant to J&K?

NEW DELHI: Amid the government order asking yatris and tourists to leave Jammu and Kashmir, Governor

Satya Pal Malik

on Saturday said he has no knowledge of any changes in the Constitutional provisions and assured that the deployment of additional forces was purely for security reasons.


Earlier, former chief minister Omar Abdullah said that Governor Malik has assured his party that no moves are planned on repealing articles 370 and 35A of the Constitution, or the state's trifurcation.

What is Article 35A?

Article 35A of the Constitution empowers J&K legislature to define state's "permanent residents" and their special rights and privileges. It was added to the Constitution through a Presidential order of 1954 with the then J&K government's concurrence.

What is its significance to J&K?

* Through 1927 and 1932 notifications, Dogra ruler of the princely state of J&K, Maharaja Hari Singh made a law that defined state subjects and their rights. The law also regulated migrants to the state. J&K then joined India through the instrument of accession signed by its ruler Hari Singh in October 1947.

* After J&K's accession, Sheikh Abdullah took over reins from the Dogra ruler. In 1949, he negotiated J&K's political relationship with New Delhi, which led to the inclusion of Article 370 in the Constitution.

* Article 370 guarantees special status to Jammu and Kashmir, restricting Union's legislative powers over three areas: defence, foreign affairs and communications.

* However, under the 1952 Delhi Agreement between Abdullah and Nehru, several provisions of the Constitution were extended to J&K via presidential order in 1954. Article 35A was also inserted then into the Constitution.

* J&K's separate Constitution was framed in 1956. It retained Maharaja's definition of permanent residents of the state which means: All persons born or settled within the state before 1911 or after having lawfully acquired immovable property resident in the state for not less than ten years or prior to that date. All emigrants from Jammu and Kashmir, including those who migrated to Pakistan, are considered state subjects. The descendants of emigrants are considered state subjects for two generations.

* Permanent resident law prohibits non-permanent residents from settling permanently in the state, acquiring immovable property, government jobs, scholarships and aid.

* However, the law was interpreted as discriminatory against the J&K women. It disqualified them from their state subject rights if they married non-permanent residents. But, in a landmark judgment in October 2002, the J&K high court held that women married to non-permanent residents will not lose their rights. But the children of such women won't have succession rights.

Why is Article 35A being debated?

* An NGO, We the Citizens, challenged Article 35A in the Supreme Court in 2014 on grounds that it was not added to the Constitution through amendment under Article 368. It was never presented before Parliament, and came into effect immediately, the group argued.

* In another case in the SC, two Kashmiri women argued that the state's laws, flowing from 35A, had disenfranchised their children.