Why weight gain isn’t about overeating, and why blaming food misses the point
Overeating is often treated like the main villain in every weight gain story. As if people are constantly eating huge portions without realizing it. But that picture is rarely true. Most overeating isn’t loud or obvious. It’s quiet, repetitive, and usually emotional. It shows up as mindless snacking while working, eating late at night because the day was exhausting, or reaching for food because it’s the quickest comfort available.
Weight gain is one of those topics everyone thinks they understand. And that’s where most of the confusion begins.
A common myth is that weight gain is always about overeating. That if someone has put on weight, they must be constantly snacking or lacking willpower. But bodies aren’t calculators. Hormones, stress, sleep, genetics, medications, and even gut health play a role. Someone can eat “normally” and still gain weight because their body is holding on, not because they’re out of control with food.
"Weight gain is much more complex than simply consuming more calories than you burn there are many factors to consider such as the amount of hormones, your body's metabolism (rate at which we burn energy), how you live your life, everything including medication and existing illness will have an effect on how much you weigh and if you should be concerned about your weight. Even people who have a healthy diet and exercise regularly can experience unexplained weight gain from internal factors which are not within their control," Dr. Manish Kumar Tomar, Senior Consultant- Gastroenterology Medanta Hospital Noida told TOI Health.
Hormonal imbalances are an important factor here, some examples of hormonal imbalance are conditions such hypothyroidism, PCOS and Cushing's disease. All of these cause an individual to have a lower metabolism and will, as a result, will cause the individual to store excess fat and particularly around their stomach area.
Cortisol is a hormone that is released into the body when you are under severe, chronic stress and can cause an increase in appetite as well as encourage the storage of more fat to be stored in your body. Sleep disturbances, such as not having enough quality sleep, cause hormones that regulate hunger, called ghrelin and leptin, to increase hunger levels and reduce the feeling of satisfaction after eating.
Another often-overlooked cause for increased weight is medication use. Medications known for having a side effect of weight gain include steroids, antidepressants, antipsychotic medications, and certain blood pressure medications. Age has an impact on this as well; the loss of muscle mass due to the natural aging process will cause the body to burn less calories when at rest than it did previously.
In some instances, fluid retention will lead to sudden weight gain rather than fat, which may be due to increased salt consumption or a heart or kidney problem. Knowledge of these factors will provide a greater understanding of the many causes of weight gain, as well as reduce the stigma associated with weight gain and show that gaining weight is not necessarily only a result of eating too much.
The researchers point out that even when two people eat similar calories and do similar activity, they can gain very different amounts of weight. That suggests individual metabolism, how our bodies use and burn energy, matters a lot. Some folks have a metabolism that slows down quickly when food is limited and stays slow even when calories increase. That’s what they call a “thrifty phenotype,” and it makes someone more prone to gaining weight and harder to lose it later.
They dive into a few biological players that might explain this difference. How fat tissue breaks down or holds on to energy, how brown fat (the calorie-burning kind) works, and how certain hormones and brain signals control how quickly we use energy all seem to play a part. For example, if your body doesn’t burn calories much during overeating or stress, you’ll end up storing more of it as fat.
This article includes expert inputs shared with TOI Health by:
Dr. Manish Kumar Tomar, Senior Consultant- Gastroenterology Medanta Hospital Noida
Inputs were used to explain why food is not the only factor that drives weight gain.
A common myth is that weight gain is always about overeating. That if someone has put on weight, they must be constantly snacking or lacking willpower. But bodies aren’t calculators. Hormones, stress, sleep, genetics, medications, and even gut health play a role. Someone can eat “normally” and still gain weight because their body is holding on, not because they’re out of control with food.
"Weight gain is much more complex than simply consuming more calories than you burn there are many factors to consider such as the amount of hormones, your body's metabolism (rate at which we burn energy), how you live your life, everything including medication and existing illness will have an effect on how much you weigh and if you should be concerned about your weight. Even people who have a healthy diet and exercise regularly can experience unexplained weight gain from internal factors which are not within their control," Dr. Manish Kumar Tomar, Senior Consultant- Gastroenterology Medanta Hospital Noida told TOI Health.
Factors that drive weight gain
Dr. Manish Kumar Tomar shared the common factors, unknown to many, that causes weight gain.Hormonal imbalances are an important factor here, some examples of hormonal imbalance are conditions such hypothyroidism, PCOS and Cushing's disease. All of these cause an individual to have a lower metabolism and will, as a result, will cause the individual to store excess fat and particularly around their stomach area.
Another often-overlooked cause for increased weight is medication use. Medications known for having a side effect of weight gain include steroids, antidepressants, antipsychotic medications, and certain blood pressure medications. Age has an impact on this as well; the loss of muscle mass due to the natural aging process will cause the body to burn less calories when at rest than it did previously.
In some instances, fluid retention will lead to sudden weight gain rather than fat, which may be due to increased salt consumption or a heart or kidney problem. Knowledge of these factors will provide a greater understanding of the many causes of weight gain, as well as reduce the stigma associated with weight gain and show that gaining weight is not necessarily only a result of eating too much.
2020 review dives into why some folks pack on pounds easier than others
We all know people who seem to gain weight just looking at food, and others who barely change no matter what they eat. This papertries to unpack why that happens, why some bodies are “thrifty” and store fat easily, while others are more “spendthrift” and resist weight gain even with the same diet. It’s not just about eating too much or moving too little. There’s more going on inside us at a metabolic level that shapes weight change.The researchers point out that even when two people eat similar calories and do similar activity, they can gain very different amounts of weight. That suggests individual metabolism, how our bodies use and burn energy, matters a lot. Some folks have a metabolism that slows down quickly when food is limited and stays slow even when calories increase. That’s what they call a “thrifty phenotype,” and it makes someone more prone to gaining weight and harder to lose it later.
They dive into a few biological players that might explain this difference. How fat tissue breaks down or holds on to energy, how brown fat (the calorie-burning kind) works, and how certain hormones and brain signals control how quickly we use energy all seem to play a part. For example, if your body doesn’t burn calories much during overeating or stress, you’ll end up storing more of it as fat.
Medical experts consulted
This article includes expert inputs shared with TOI Health by:
Dr. Manish Kumar Tomar, Senior Consultant- Gastroenterology Medanta Hospital Noida
Inputs were used to explain why food is not the only factor that drives weight gain.
Popular from Business
- In a first, Brahmaputra 'rail-road twin tunnel' gets Cabinet nod to transform North-east connectivity
- Cognizant flags reputational risks in offshore outsourcing
- Big push for Assam: PM Modi inaugrates Rs 5,450 crore worth projects; IIM Guwahati, Kumar Bhaskar Varma Setu & more
- China to remove tariffs on most African imports from May 1, expands zero-duty policy across continent
- ‘Plumbers of the tech world’: Why Indian IT sector shouldn’t worry about AI impact - JPMorgan explains new areas of work
end of article
Trending Stories
- Aircraft imports from US may boost tourism, cut airfares: Piyush Goyal
- Govt clears Rs 10,000 crore Startup India Fund of Funds 2.0 to boost early-stage, deep-tech startups
- US inflation cools to 2.4% in January, near five-year low as gas and housing costs ease
- US adds Alibaba, Baidu to military-linked firms list supporting China: Report
- US stocks today: Wall Street steadies after softer inflation data; AI disruption fears keep markets cautious
18:01 India set to drive global growth, emerge as new engine of world economy: PM Modi- Infosys pays average 85% performance bonus for Q3; payout to be credited with February salary
Photostories
- Top 5 Margot Robbie movies that are a must-watch on OTT
- 5 invisible AI features in modern luxury cars that drivers rarely notice
- After Shahid Kapoor led 'O'Romeo,' 6 Bollywood gangster films to stream on OTT that are inspired by the underworld
- Margot Robbie's most iconic on-screen looks: Gothic lore, barbiecore and beyond
- 5 famous global fabrics you didn’t know were originally Indian
- Maha Shivratri 2026: How to make Sabudana Tikki for evening snacking
- Historic touchdown in Assam: PM Modi lands at Northeast’s first highway ELF; IAF stages aerial show — In pics
- Top 5 real estate hotspots in Navi Mumbai driving investment and residential demand in 2026
- From Kapil Sharma to Krushna Abhishek- Richest Indian comedians and their net worth
- How RERA ensures transparency in Real Estate transactions
Up Next
Start a Conversation
Post comment