The Times of India, TNN, Updated: May 22, 2016, 04.51 PM ISTCritic's Rating: 3.5
If there is one regret that Mahanagar@Kolkata can grip the
viewer, it is about how Indian film-makers chose to overlook a powerhouse of
talent like Arun Mukhopadhyay and not work with him in the recent years.
It is
tad sad that it took his director son, Suman Mukhopadhyay, to cast him as the
unassuming Biren in M@K. But for the film-going audience, this too is a bonus.
From mannerisms to dialogue delivery (especially, the way he uses slangs), Arun
Mukhopadhyay gets it delightfully right and also brings along a sense of
quirkiness in the second story that otherwise seems like a dark tale of a man
suffering from paranoia.
Arun Mukhopadhyay’s character is also
the thread that stitches together the other two stories of the film’s
narrative. The first story is about a night on the premises of a state hospital
where a relative of his employer, played by Anjan Dutt, has been admitted. This
relative, played by Chandan Roy Sanyal, turns out to be the protagonist of the
third story that deals with the urban fear of being trapped in a loveless
marriage. In a surprising twist of fate, Chandan is also the same guy who drives
in an injured goal-keeper to the hospital where the latter’s father
(Biplab Chatterjee) goes on to befriend Dutt when he is waiting for Chandan to
recover.
What makes M@K exciting as a film is the way the director
interconnects three different stories of Nabarun Bhattacharya — Ek Tukro
Nyloner Dori, Amar Kono Bhoy Nei To? and Aangshik Chandragrahan. The first two
stories have an organic connect effortlessly blend into each other. Both in
terms of form and content, the third story follows a slightly standalone model.
Too many elements come into the fore and the director, consciously or otherwise,
exposes the fact that he is grappling with a form where he has to constantly
shuttle between the real and the surreal. From Bergman and Nandigram to Sati
Daho and theory of suicides, this section of the film bleeds with a heavy burden
of knowledge. In the process, the hallucinating Chandan stops just short of
reaching a height that could have been attained to express the real and surreal
texture of all the characters in the film, and in extension, our Mahanagar
too.
Music, however, does ample justice to the film. In his first
outing as a film music composer, Fossils frontman Rupam Islam is impressive. The
edgy sound of his numbers goes well with the feel, texture and the cadence of
the film. The new-age title of the film with the @ sign tucked in between
Ray’s Mahanagar and Suman’s Kolkata comes alive as the end credits
roll with Rupam singing his first Bangla rap! At a time when Bengali cinema is
riding high partly on remakes, M@K shows promise. Those who love Suman’s
style of film-making will leave home appreciating his eye for detail that
contextualises the film in contemporary times where sex traffic, mafia wars,
menace of bird flu are as endemic reasons for phobia as the stress of crumbling
relationships where out-of-love couples are also incapable of having tiffs to
sort out their differences.