Are we beggars? Goa fire survivor claims collector’s office keeps asking for bank details; says don’t want aid, only justice
GOA: The flames of the blaze that burned through a Goa nightclub seem to have stretched limbs across time to not only destroy Bhavna Joshi's future with her husband but also scorch the memories she has collected with her sisters since childhood.
Her husband, Vinod Kumar (43), and three sisters—Kamla Joshi (42), Anita Joshi (41), and Saroj Joshi (39)—were among the 25 victims who perished in the massive fire on December 6 in north Goa.
Bhavna, who was also at the nightclub, survived the tragedy with injuries. Amid her grief, her only plea is for justice for the loss of her loved ones.
Bhavna sits in a corner of her home in northeast Delhi's Karawal Nagar with heavy eyes, as relatives tiptoe around her, unsure of how to console her.
"We were enjoying ourselves. Everything was normal. Suddenly, there was fire," she recalls.
It was small at first, but they could not control it, she says, unable to hold back tears.
"In seconds, it became huge and uncontrollable. My husband and my sisters were trapped in it. I saw everything," she says.
Her voice stiffens when she speaks of the calls she has been receiving from the Goa collector's office.
"They keep asking for bank details. They say they will give us two lakh rupees," she says.
"Are we beggars? Will two lakh rupees bring back my family? Will it return my sisters? Have some shame. I do not want any compensation. I just want justice," Bhavna says.
In another quiet corner of the house sits her elderly mother, Meena, who watched her three daughters leave for a holiday and never return, while her fourth daughter grieves for her husband.
The magnitude of her loss, Meena says, is too large to express.
"I lost my children. What do you expect from a mother who lost four children at this age?" she asks.
"I lost everything in that fire. The culprits must not get away with bail or just a fine. They must face the consequences. I only want justice," Meena says.
Naveen, Kamla's husband and the elder brother of Vinod, says the family would not have even found out what happened to their loved ones if not for Bhavna's survival.
"If my brother's wife had not survived, we would not have known anything," he says, adding that identification was difficult since there were 25 people who died.
Blaming the authorities for negligence, Naveen alleges that the bodies were kept in such a condition that it is difficult to describe.
"There are many restaurants and clubs where rules are not followed. Action should be taken so this does not happen again. Today, it happened to us. Tomorrow, it may be someone else," he says.
For Bhavna, if the the dark shadow cast over her life can be mitigated at all, it would be only through justice.
She keeps repeating her demand. "I just want justice for my family. Nothing more, nothing less," she says.
Their relatives earlier told PTI that the four sisters had been planning their Goa vacation for months, hoping for a few days of rest now that their children were older and no longer wholly dependent on them.
Vinod had accompanied them so that they would feel safe and supported during the journey. The five left their Karawal Nagar homes with excitement, expecting a break from routine.
In the early hours of December 6, a massive fire ripped through the ‘Birch by Romeo Lane’ nightclub in Arpora, Goa, claiming 25 lives.
On Thursday, a Goa court sent Ajay Gupta, who claimed to be a silent partner and investor in the nightclub, to seven days of police custody. Gupta was brought from Delhi on Wednesday night on a transit remand for questioning and was taken to the Anjuna police station for further investigation, officials said.
Earlier, a Look Out circular had been issued against him. Five managers and staff members have already been arrested in connection with the blaze. Meanwhile, co-owners Saurabh and Gaurav Luthra, who fled to Phuket, Thailand, shortly after the incident, have been detained by local authorities.
(With agency inputs)
Get an chance to win ₹5000 Amazon Voucher by taking part in India's Biggest Habit Index! Take the survey here
Bhavna, who was also at the nightclub, survived the tragedy with injuries. Amid her grief, her only plea is for justice for the loss of her loved ones.
Bhavna sits in a corner of her home in northeast Delhi's Karawal Nagar with heavy eyes, as relatives tiptoe around her, unsure of how to console her.
"We were enjoying ourselves. Everything was normal. Suddenly, there was fire," she recalls.
It was small at first, but they could not control it, she says, unable to hold back tears.
"In seconds, it became huge and uncontrollable. My husband and my sisters were trapped in it. I saw everything," she says.
"They keep asking for bank details. They say they will give us two lakh rupees," she says.
"Are we beggars? Will two lakh rupees bring back my family? Will it return my sisters? Have some shame. I do not want any compensation. I just want justice," Bhavna says.
In another quiet corner of the house sits her elderly mother, Meena, who watched her three daughters leave for a holiday and never return, while her fourth daughter grieves for her husband.
The magnitude of her loss, Meena says, is too large to express.
"I lost my children. What do you expect from a mother who lost four children at this age?" she asks.
"I lost everything in that fire. The culprits must not get away with bail or just a fine. They must face the consequences. I only want justice," Meena says.
Naveen, Kamla's husband and the elder brother of Vinod, says the family would not have even found out what happened to their loved ones if not for Bhavna's survival.
"If my brother's wife had not survived, we would not have known anything," he says, adding that identification was difficult since there were 25 people who died.
Blaming the authorities for negligence, Naveen alleges that the bodies were kept in such a condition that it is difficult to describe.
"There are many restaurants and clubs where rules are not followed. Action should be taken so this does not happen again. Today, it happened to us. Tomorrow, it may be someone else," he says.
For Bhavna, if the the dark shadow cast over her life can be mitigated at all, it would be only through justice.
She keeps repeating her demand. "I just want justice for my family. Nothing more, nothing less," she says.
Their relatives earlier told PTI that the four sisters had been planning their Goa vacation for months, hoping for a few days of rest now that their children were older and no longer wholly dependent on them.
Vinod had accompanied them so that they would feel safe and supported during the journey. The five left their Karawal Nagar homes with excitement, expecting a break from routine.
In the early hours of December 6, a massive fire ripped through the ‘Birch by Romeo Lane’ nightclub in Arpora, Goa, claiming 25 lives.
On Thursday, a Goa court sent Ajay Gupta, who claimed to be a silent partner and investor in the nightclub, to seven days of police custody. Gupta was brought from Delhi on Wednesday night on a transit remand for questioning and was taken to the Anjuna police station for further investigation, officials said.
Earlier, a Look Out circular had been issued against him. Five managers and staff members have already been arrested in connection with the blaze. Meanwhile, co-owners Saurabh and Gaurav Luthra, who fled to Phuket, Thailand, shortly after the incident, have been detained by local authorities.
(With agency inputs)
Get an chance to win ₹5000 Amazon Voucher by taking part in India's Biggest Habit Index! Take the survey here
Expand
Top Comment
n
null
8 hours ago
Ne patient. Modi is working 25 hours a day to turn Indians like you into beggars. Too bad you didn't die. Your family would have got 2 lacs.Read allPost comment
Popular from City
- 42 companies, 1 Delhi address: Can Luthra empire survive its own fire?
- ‘We were getting late’: Local delayed, commuters stop Vande Bharat for 20 minutes in Punjab; GRP, RPF scan videos
- NHAI set to redesign Kochi bypass as traffic projections surge
- Watch: At 70-ft tall, 'world's largest Messi statue' erected in Kolkata ahead of GOAT tour; Z-category shield for football king
- Centre wants Noida airport RRTS link from Sarai Kale Khan, via City Centre
end of article
Trending Stories
- Megan Thee Stallion cheating rumor on Klay Thompson explodes online as breakup speculation spreads
- Giannis Antetokounmpo to Miami Heat? Milwaukee Bucks star's surprising trade wish list puts team in a strong position
- 'Something wrong in HC': SC scraps plea against SIT probe into Karur stampede; TN govt says won't interfere with CBI investigation
04:55 Donald Trump wants to be part of India-China-Russia club? All about Core-5 buzz; which countries are on the list- Who is Paige Shiver and why her name surfaced during the Michigan–Sherrone Moore controversy
- Venus Williams and Andrea Preti combined net worth in 2025: Tennis legend, career, family, business income, and more
- Delhi’s school fee law goes live: What changes for parents and schools this academic year
Featured in city
- Andhra Pradesh accident fallout: Night-time travel ban on heavy vehicles on ghat roads in Alluri district
- 2020 Delhi riots: HC notes victims, accused never faulted probe; court questions basis of petitioners’ SIT plea
07:15 Are we beggars? Goa fire survivor claims collector’s office keeps asking for bank details; says don’t want aid, only justice- Watch: At 70-ft tall, 'worlds largest Messi statue' erected in Kolkata ahead of GOAT tour; Z-category shield for football king
- More skeletons out of Luthra brothers' closet: Landowner says officials secretly changed property status; how move cleared path for nightclub
- Bengaluru’s 1st driverless metro: Namma Metro’s Pink Line enters next-gen era
Photostories
- Curiosity Corner: Why is Lord Shiva always calm even when things go wrong?
- 10 cardio exercises that are equal to walking 5000 steps
- From 'Andhadhun' to ‘Jaane Jaan’: Bollywood movies with the most twisted endings
- From Ranbir Kapoor’s congee to Ananya Panday’s gajar ka halwa: Actors and their favourite winter dishes
- ‘Padayappa’ to ‘Petta’: Rajinikanth films that will explode your fan-boy heart on the Superstar’s birthday!
- 5 longest animals found across the world
- Kidney damage: How “healthy” supplements and vitamins can sneakily hurt you
- From Border to Chhaava: 'Dhurandhar' Akshaye Khanna’s best performances you need to watch on OTT
- Chef Sanjeev Kapoor's creative and exotic fiber-rich broccoli recipes for winter months
- Sonam Kapoor just gave us the winter-wedding maternity look of the season
Videos
03:28 India Speeds Up Visas For Chinese Businesses Amid Thaw In Ties; Beijing Calls It 'Positive Move'04:13 India's Ambassador To UNESCO Hails Inscription Of Diwali On Intangible Cultural Heritage List04:14 Putin Keeps Sharif Waiting In Ashgabat, Desperate Pakistan PM Gate-Crashes Meeting With Erdogan04:55 Is Trump Planning A New Core-5 Superclub With India As Central Power? Inside The Buzz In Washington04:18 IMF’s New Conditions Expose Pakistan’s Deep Economic Faultlines Amid $7 Billion Rescue Package06:52 Lashkar Praises Munir’s CDF Elevation, Issues Threats To Kabul And Deepens Pakistan Proxy Crisis04:29 'Hindus Are Lathi-Charged': Anurag Thakur Attacks Tamil Nadu Govt Over Karthigai Deepam Row06:21 Congress Shows Rift As Odisha MLA Writes To Sonia Gandhi Seeking Kharge’s Removal, Priyanka’s Rise05:34 Trump’s $1 Million Gold Card Explained: What America’s Costliest Visa Means For Indian Applicants
Up Next