'Mental worry is more devastating ...': Supreme Court quotes Sanskrit shloka while allowing passive euthanasia
NEW DELHI: "You are not giving up on your son. You are allowing him to leave with dignity. It reflects the depth of your selfless love and devotion towards him," Supreme Court told the parents, sharing their emotions on allowing passive euthanasia of their 32-year old son Harish Rana.
A bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K V Viswanathan deeply appreciated the effort of the parents in taking care of their son for the last thirteen years and said its order would end the suffering of Harish. It said it is not as if their agony will be entirely wiped away by its order but the distress that they experience due to what Harish is undergoing will at least be over.
Quoting an ancient Sanskrit shloka, Justice Viswanathan said: ‘Between the funeral fire and the mental worry, it is the mental worry which is more devastating. While the funeral fire burns only the dead body, the mental worry burns the living one.'
"..a mention needs to be made of the love and affection by which the parents and the siblings have nursed Harish for the last more than 12 years. Harish has been in a vegetative state but the parents and siblings have left no stone unturned in ensuring best treatment for Harish. It is only when the matter reached a point of no return, that to relieve Harish from what he is undergoing they have resorted to this legal course of action. One can only imagine the agony they would have undergone during this period," Justice Viswanathan said .
"To Harish's family, we want to acknowledge the deep emotional weight this decision carries. This decision can feel like an act of surrender, but we believe it is, in truth, an act of profound compassion and courage," Justice Pardiwala noted in his verdict..
"Our decision today does not neatly fit within logic and reason alone. It sits in a space between love, loss, medicine and mercy. This decision is not about choosing death, but is rather one of not artificially prolonging life. It is the decision to withdraw life sustaining treatment when that treatment no longer heals, restores, or meaningfully improves life. It is allowing nature to take its course when medicine can only delay the inevitable because survival is not always the same as living," he said.
Israel Iran War
- US-Israel-Iran War News Live Updates: Iran says it targeted Israeli military intelligence & naval base; fresh explosions heard in Dubai
- Middle Easat crisis: MEA condemns attack on India-bound Thai ship; remarks innocent lives lost in conflict 'unacceptable'
- 'Legitimate targets': Iran issues warning to US tech firms including Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Nvidia
Quoting an ancient Sanskrit shloka, Justice Viswanathan said: ‘Between the funeral fire and the mental worry, it is the mental worry which is more devastating. While the funeral fire burns only the dead body, the mental worry burns the living one.'
"..a mention needs to be made of the love and affection by which the parents and the siblings have nursed Harish for the last more than 12 years. Harish has been in a vegetative state but the parents and siblings have left no stone unturned in ensuring best treatment for Harish. It is only when the matter reached a point of no return, that to relieve Harish from what he is undergoing they have resorted to this legal course of action. One can only imagine the agony they would have undergone during this period," Justice Viswanathan said .
"Our decision today does not neatly fit within logic and reason alone. It sits in a space between love, loss, medicine and mercy. This decision is not about choosing death, but is rather one of not artificially prolonging life. It is the decision to withdraw life sustaining treatment when that treatment no longer heals, restores, or meaningfully improves life. It is allowing nature to take its course when medicine can only delay the inevitable because survival is not always the same as living," he said.
You Can Also Check: Delhi AQI
|
Bank Holidays in Delhi |
Gold Rate Today in Delhi |
Silver Rate Today in Delhi
Popular from City
- LPG shortage: We’ll navigate the situation, PM Modi says
- 'Constantly humiliated, caused mental trauma': Mumbai dentist's chilling death note shocks kin; how troubled relationship ended in tragedy
- Jwala delivers 5 cubs at Kuno National Park; India’s cheetah population rises to 53
- 'Brain-dead' woman jolted back to life by pothole in UP
- Madhya Pradesh horror: Man bludgeons 16-year-old boy to death with hammer, eats his flesh and drinks blood
end of article
Trending Stories
- US-Israel-Iran War News Live Updates: UAE embassy in Iraq attacked, Hezbollah drones target Israel
- IPL 2026 schedule announcement Live updates: RCB vs SRH to kick off IPL 2026 at Chinnaswamy on March 28
- 'Non-Sanatanis' barred from Badrinath and Kedarnath temples
- SC imposes life ban on three academics for 'corruption' chapter, seeks action on posts
- Close shave for Farooq Abdullah: Man aims gun at ex-J&K CM, pinned down in time - CCTV footage
- 'Legitimate targets': Iran issues warning to US tech firms including Google, Amazon, Microsoft, Nvidia
09:49 Middle Easat crisis: MEA condemns attack on India-bound Thai ship; remarks innocent lives lost in conflict 'unacceptable'
Featured in city
- LPG shortage: We’ll navigate the situation, PM Modi says
- Motion for Speaker's removal defeated after fiery debate in Parliament
- 60 sites identified to relocate 2,800 industries outside Outer Ring Road in Hyderabad
- ‘Without money, we will die here too’: Why fear of war has failed to deter Indian workers looking to head for Middle East
- 'Donald Trump’s yes man’: Arvind Kejriwal’s scathing attack on PM Narendra Modi amid LPG crisis
03:37 Who is Harish Rana? Ghaziabad man in vegetative state for 12 years at centre of Supreme Court's passive euthanasia ruling
Photostories
- Devoleena Bhattacharjee gets emotional recalling caring for her mother during schizophrenia attacks from the age of 11; says brother’s death led to a phase of depression
- A red Chanderi saree, royal bandhgala and Mumbai sunset: Pictures from Kritika Kamra-Gaurav Kapur's intimate Bandra home wedding
- Mahesh Babu-Namrata Shirodkar: Love story born on 'Vamsi' sets, sealed in private vows
- Hardik Pandya to Abhishek Sharma: Indian players flash diamond studs and chains during T20 World Cup 2026 triumph
- 5 key features that make cruiser bikes comfortable for highway riding
- How to make South Indian Curd Rice for dinner to keep the stomach cool
- The ‘3-hour dinner rule’: Doctors say this simple change could improve heart health and longevity
- Is collecting airline miles still worth it? 5 things travellers should know
- 7 signs you are in a healthy relationship
- 7 birds that use Earth's magnetic field to travel the globe
Videos
05:24 No LPG Shortage: Govt Unveils Plan To Prioritise Homes, Hospitals, Schools05:52 Preparing Against Joint China & Pakistan Threat, India Buys More Weapons Than Any Nation : Report14:48 ‘Parliament Is Not A Party Office’: TMC’s Sayani Ghosh Targets Modi Govt During Speaker Trust Motion06:56 Lok Sabha Drama Ends With Voice Vote Defeating Opposition Move Against Speaker Om Birla08:05 First Group Of Indian Students In Iran To Head Towards Armenia Border Amid Security Concerns08:26 ‘FOMO Gandhi’: BJP MP Anurag Thakur's Viral Dig At Rahul Gandhi, Calls Him 'Leader Of Propaganda'07:12 'Speaker Above Party Lines': Amit Shah Attacks Congress Over Rare Lok Sabha No Confidence Motion03:07 Learning from Iran, Indian Army Conducts Live Firing Drill Against Drone Swarms At Pokhran07:37 PM Modi Assures Safety Of Indians Amid West Asia War, Slams Cong-Left For ‘Creating Panic’
Up Next
Start a Conversation
Post comment