Smallcap stocks mark strong comeback after heavy losses, is it revival or bull trap?

After nine grueling sessions that wiped out months of gains for retail investors, smallcap stocks are making a strong return. The Nifty Smallcap 250 index, which remains in bear market territory and is down 22% from its peak, rose 2% on Wednesday. Stocks like Aegis Logistics, GRSE, Netweb Tech, and Minda Corp saw impressive double-digit gains.

However the question remains: Is this the beginning of a genuine revival, or just a temporary bull trap before another downturn?

If the recent sell-off is a correction in a larger bull market, analysts believe the worst may be behind us. But if this marks the start of a deeper bear market, history suggests the pain could persist much longer. Investor Ajay Bagga warned, "We have seen much shallower bear markets, and in about 12 months, most of the damage is done. If we are in that phase, there could be another 5% to 10% correction in the leading indices over the next seven months."

The Q3 earnings season proved to be more difficult than anticipated for smallcap companies. According to JM Financial, 50% of smallcap companies missed earnings expectations, compared to 34% for midcaps and 28% for largecaps.

Nuvama analysts pointed out that small and midcap (SMID) profits, which had been outperforming largecaps for most of FY24, have now started underperforming, marking the second consecutive quarter of underperformance. "This is largely due to the domestic slowdown, which affects SMIDs more than largecaps. If you exclude BFSI, SMID profit growth has fallen sharply and is now contracting on a YoY basis for the second quarter in a row," Nuvama explained.

Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) are a key factor in this struggle. With a massive Rs 1 lakh crore in equity outflows this year, combined with a weakening rupee and rising bond yields, smallcap stocks are struggling to recover from their selling spree.

"High-frequency indicators might start hinting at a turnaround soon," said V K Vijayakumar of Geojit Financial Services.

Despite the challenges, some analysts see a longer-term opportunity. Citi Research forecasts the Nifty to reach 26,000 by December 2025, while Morgan Stanley believes India is on track to resume its emerging-market outperformance, thanks to macro stability and rising consumption.

Vikas Khemani of Carnelian Advisors emphasized that investors should focus on the company, business model, and management rather than market size. "If you like a particular company with strong management that can deliver over time, this is a great time to buy, regardless of whether it’s a small or large company," he said.

The next few weeks will determine whether smallcaps are on the verge of a comeback or heading toward another sell-off.
Stay informed with the latest business news, updates on bank holidays and public holidays.

Unlock Investment Potential: Enroll in ET's Stock Valuation Workshop - Batch 3. Secure Your Spot Now!