Rate cut looks uncertain despite slowing growth
MUMBAI: Despite growth numbers coming in sharply lower and all-round calls for reduction in interest rates to support growth, the monetary policy committee (MPC) will find reducing rates a challenge.
Lower-than-expected Q2 GDP growth numbers at 5.4 per cent have increased pressure on RBI's MPC to reduce interest rates even as the expectation of a softer policy led to bond yields falling on Friday.
The rate-setting panel has also faced pressure from govt, with commerce minister Piyush Goyal suggesting that food prices should be excluded from consideration and finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman advocating for softer rates to boost investment and growth.
But while monetary policy cannot impact the prices of tomatoes, onion or potatoes, it can reduce demand and bring down overall prices which will soften headline inflation.
According to Shreya Sodhani, economist with Barclays, RBI is expected to keep policy rates unchanged this week despite weaker growth, 'according primacy to price stability'. "We highlighted that a weaker-than-expected Q3 GDP print may prompt the MPC to ease monetary policy, but the timing would depend on the outlook of growth and inflation," Sodhani said in a report.
In the MPC meeting in Oct, of the three newly inducted external members, Nagesh Kumar was the only one who called for an immediate 25 basis point rate cut. Earlier in Aug, outgoing members Jayanth Varma and Ashima Goyal had voted for a rate cut. Varma was strident in advocating for lower rates and had said that the status quo in rates undermines India's growth potential.
"The outlook for H2 FY25 is decidedly mixed. We foresee a likely improvement in rural demand owing to the robust growth in kharif foodgrain output and upbeat outlook for rabi crops amid replenished reservoir levels, as well as expectations of a back-ended pick up in govt capex," Aditi Nayar, chief economist with Icra, said. But in light of the spike in inflation, Icra expects the MPC to cut rates in Feb at the earliest if inflation recedes.While not many expect RBI to cut the repo rate there is an expectation that it will take measures to ease liquidity and bring down interest rates in the money market.
The rate-setting panel has also faced pressure from govt, with commerce minister Piyush Goyal suggesting that food prices should be excluded from consideration and finance minister Nirmala Sitharaman advocating for softer rates to boost investment and growth.
But while monetary policy cannot impact the prices of tomatoes, onion or potatoes, it can reduce demand and bring down overall prices which will soften headline inflation.
According to Shreya Sodhani, economist with Barclays, RBI is expected to keep policy rates unchanged this week despite weaker growth, 'according primacy to price stability'. "We highlighted that a weaker-than-expected Q3 GDP print may prompt the MPC to ease monetary policy, but the timing would depend on the outlook of growth and inflation," Sodhani said in a report.
In the MPC meeting in Oct, of the three newly inducted external members, Nagesh Kumar was the only one who called for an immediate 25 basis point rate cut. Earlier in Aug, outgoing members Jayanth Varma and Ashima Goyal had voted for a rate cut. Varma was strident in advocating for lower rates and had said that the status quo in rates undermines India's growth potential.
"The outlook for H2 FY25 is decidedly mixed. We foresee a likely improvement in rural demand owing to the robust growth in kharif foodgrain output and upbeat outlook for rabi crops amid replenished reservoir levels, as well as expectations of a back-ended pick up in govt capex," Aditi Nayar, chief economist with Icra, said. But in light of the spike in inflation, Icra expects the MPC to cut rates in Feb at the earliest if inflation recedes.While not many expect RBI to cut the repo rate there is an expectation that it will take measures to ease liquidity and bring down interest rates in the money market.
Top Comment
Yoga N Mani
45 minutes ago
'To explain to the puzzled Minister why "RATE CUT LOOKS UNCERTAIN DESPITE SLOWING GROWTH I reproduce the following Comment which I posted on 29 Nov. "Wall Street Journal has written "The world’s fifth-largest economy grew 5.4% from a year earlier in the July-September quarter. That was the slowest pace of growth since the fourth quarter of 2022....Though WSJ has written "SOFT MANUFACTURING AND INVESTMENT ACTIVITY AND WEAK URBAN CONSUMPTION" as three individual causes for the fall in growth, I submit that WEAK CONSUMPTION is the causal factor for SOFT MANUFACTURING ; and SOFT MANUFACTURING is ,in turn, the causal factor for weak INVESTMENT ACTIVITY. At the bottom of this tale of woe lies WEAK CONSUMPTION, the causal factor of which is large-scale unemployment , but the grossly unequal distribution of Income and Wealth in India HIDES this causal factor. PUBLIC Consumption , as % of GDP fell from 12.811% in April 2023 to 10.153% in April 2024, though 2024 was the Year of CONSPICUOUS CONSUMPTION BY THE RICH OF INDIA AT A WEDDING.We read the PER CAPITA GDP of India as $ 2,301.418 in 2022 (the last report available). We convert the $ into Rupee by multiplying it by today's Exchange Rate of 84.45 rupees to a Dollar . Rs 1,94,355 per person per year , or Rs 13,60,483 per Hindu family of seven per annum (including Father's Parents) If it is a "hum panch hamara pandrah" family , the Family Income is Rs 38,87,100 per annum because of Corrupt Kangress which robs Mangal Sutra . We forget that the per Capita income divides the Tata, Birla, Ambani Adani, Cricketers annual Income to all Indians and makes the Beggar want a Benz Car Wall Street Journal has speculated that the weak growth of 5.40% WOULD MAKE RBI ease the Interest Rate so that Investments will be made. However , so long as India is the land of unemployed which cannot raise the level of consumption and encourage Investment and production, EASING OF INTEREST WILL NOT GROW THE ECONOMY. A strong proof of this conclusion is that from 2019, readily-available Indian Rupee is being SENT OUT OF INDIA FOR INVESTMENT ABROAD"Having proven my merit by ANTICIPATING the Minister's question and answering it two days before he asked it , I hereby apply to Leader Ji to appoint me as Economic Adviser and maintain the unbroken Chain of Tamil EAs with "Shubh Laabh" Mani in their name. (all before me were Subramanians, I'm Yoga Mani) .Since I will advise for the Kalyan of India, I will not accept a Salary and since it is not necessary for me to read Government's falsified Data to advise the Government, I will work from my home in Kumbakonam and pay all charges on the house.Read allPost comment
Popular from Business
- 'Every attack makes us stronger': Gautam Adani on US allegations
- Bank Holidays December 2024: On what days will banks be closed in December? Check state-wise holiday list
- Indian Railways’ first bullet train, with 250 kmph average speed & Kavach 5.0, is being made in India - check details
- Finance minister Sitharaman encourages regional rural banks to onboard customers to digital services by December
- India's GDP growth slows to 2-year low of 5.4% in Q2, adding pressure on RBI to cut rates
end of article
Trending Stories
- India Q2 GDP Growth 2024 Live Updates: Indian economy likely slowed down in July-September quarter
- PAN 2.0: Will You Get A New PAN Card & Will Your Existing PAN Become Invalid? What’s Special About PAN With Enhanced QR Code? Top 10 Points Taxpayers Should Know
- Bank Holidays December 2024: On what days will banks be closed in December? Check state-wise holiday list
- Special Vande Bharat trains for Kashmir! Indian Railways to introduce new Vande Bharat trains with ‘heating’ features - check details
- High-speed 280 kmph trains soon! Indian Railways to manufacture bullet trains - check top features
- IAF’s Sukhoi-30 MKI fighter jets: India, Russia exploring joint production of Sukhoi engine
- Stock market today: BSE Sensex surges over 700 points; Nifty50 above 24,100
Visual Stories
- NEET UG 2024 result awaited: Top 10 NIRF-ranked medical colleges of India
- 7 New Expected Bullet Train Routes in India
- 10 Upcoming High-Speed Expressways That Will Change Highway Travel In India
- 8 Transformational Indian Railways Projects You Shouldn’t Miss
- Why Sensex, Nifty50 Hit New Highs, M-Cap At $5 Trillion: Top Reasons
UP NEXT